cool007
New member
- Joined:
- Mar 29, 2009
- Posts:
- 688
- Liked Posts:
- 2
- Location:
- Mundelein
The 2 main ingredients that Point Guard needs to be very good on the court.
1) A Talented Big Man who can score and demand attention.
and
2) 3pt Shooters/Scorers - more or elite the better.
Now, let's look at the PGs that actually have BOTH of these.
* Rondo = KG (talented big man) + Allen/House/Pierce (Good 3pt shooters/Scorers)
* Nelson = Dwight (talented big man) + Carter/Hedo/others (Good 3pt shooters/Scorers)
* Mo Will. = Shaq/Z (talented big man) + LBJ/Gibson/Parker (Good 3pt shooters/Scorers)
* Bibby = Horford + JJ/others
* Calderon = Bosh + Barney/Hedo/others
* Harris = Lopez + Carter/Hassell/others (last year)
* Jennings = Bogut + Redd/Delfino/Illyasova
* Arenas = Jamison + Butler
* Parker = Duncan + Bonner/Mason/Ginobli
* Chris Paul = D. West + Peja (41% 3pt shooter)/Posey etc
* Nash = Amare + Richardson/Frye/Barbosa
* Deron = Boozer + Okur/others
* Billups = Nene + Melo/JR Smith/others
* B Diddy = Kaman + Gordon/Butler etc.
* Westbrook = Green + Durant
Now look at Rose:
Does he have a Talented big man that can score on a consistent basis??? NO
Does he have 3pt shooters/threat that requires any attention??? NO
Does he have another scorer that scores 20+ a game??? NO.
I am not saying it automatically makes Rose better but we all forgot that when we drafted Rose, we knew that he was a RAW player and would take
couple of years to develop. I know he started off nicely and won ROY award but that doesn't change the fact that he is still RAW.
He needs players around him - especially those 2 ingredients that I said above. That would make that development MUCH faster and smoother.
Ofcourse I should have included couple other things like a great scorer next to him to take pressure off of him and another big thing is Coaching,
which we don't have as far as teaching/mentoring/motivating goes.
The whole idea of this thread is to let people know to put things into perspective. Especially when people start comparing to development of guys
like Rondo/CP3/Deron/etc. Those guys already had these 2 ingredients available when they started their career. Rose has neither of these right now.
1) A Talented Big Man who can score and demand attention.
and
2) 3pt Shooters/Scorers - more or elite the better.
Now, let's look at the PGs that actually have BOTH of these.
* Rondo = KG (talented big man) + Allen/House/Pierce (Good 3pt shooters/Scorers)
* Nelson = Dwight (talented big man) + Carter/Hedo/others (Good 3pt shooters/Scorers)
* Mo Will. = Shaq/Z (talented big man) + LBJ/Gibson/Parker (Good 3pt shooters/Scorers)
* Bibby = Horford + JJ/others
* Calderon = Bosh + Barney/Hedo/others
* Harris = Lopez + Carter/Hassell/others (last year)
* Jennings = Bogut + Redd/Delfino/Illyasova
* Arenas = Jamison + Butler
* Parker = Duncan + Bonner/Mason/Ginobli
* Chris Paul = D. West + Peja (41% 3pt shooter)/Posey etc
* Nash = Amare + Richardson/Frye/Barbosa
* Deron = Boozer + Okur/others
* Billups = Nene + Melo/JR Smith/others
* B Diddy = Kaman + Gordon/Butler etc.
* Westbrook = Green + Durant
Now look at Rose:
Does he have a Talented big man that can score on a consistent basis??? NO
Does he have 3pt shooters/threat that requires any attention??? NO
Does he have another scorer that scores 20+ a game??? NO.
I am not saying it automatically makes Rose better but we all forgot that when we drafted Rose, we knew that he was a RAW player and would take
couple of years to develop. I know he started off nicely and won ROY award but that doesn't change the fact that he is still RAW.
He needs players around him - especially those 2 ingredients that I said above. That would make that development MUCH faster and smoother.
Ofcourse I should have included couple other things like a great scorer next to him to take pressure off of him and another big thing is Coaching,
which we don't have as far as teaching/mentoring/motivating goes.
The whole idea of this thread is to let people know to put things into perspective. Especially when people start comparing to development of guys
like Rondo/CP3/Deron/etc. Those guys already had these 2 ingredients available when they started their career. Rose has neither of these right now.