Is NCAA 11 Worth It

Is NCAA Football 11 Worth Buying


  • Total voters
    9

USCChiFan

Crow's Nest
Donator
Joined:
Apr 16, 2010
Posts:
8,003
Liked Posts:
1,105
Location:
Behind you
I've been hearing more bad than good lately, w/ all of the glitches, fumbling issues, and problems w/ ODs. I was gonna get it last week, but now I have my doubts about this game.
 

payton 34ever

Well-known member
Joined:
Apr 21, 2010
Posts:
1,416
Liked Posts:
810
Location:
West Des Moines, IA
They don't include FCS teams in the game (somehow they were able to back on PS2 in the early 2000s, but they can't figure it out now). Until they do that, my answer will always be "no".
 

MRN

MRNeverwearthesamething
Donator
Joined:
Apr 17, 2010
Posts:
1,385
Liked Posts:
213
Location:
Springfield,IL
They don't include FCS teams in the game (somehow they were able to back on PS2 in the early 2000s, but they can't figure it out now). Until they do that, my answer will always be "no".

So because they don't have Eastern Illinois and company, you are going to miss out on USC, Alabama, and the rest of the relevant teams?

Makes sense...
 

cubsneedmiracle

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
May 28, 2010
Posts:
7,474
Liked Posts:
1,778
So because they don't have Eastern Illinois and company, you are going to miss out on USC, Alabama, and the rest of the relevant teams?

Makes sense...

Everybody is relevant.
 

HighJump31

N7
Donator
Joined:
Apr 17, 2010
Posts:
3,761
Liked Posts:
1,327
Location:
Lake County, Illinois
I've read EA has some feature in the game completely turned off for now until they fix it. It's why when you start a game it'll say something like "download failure. This game will not count towards your team" or something along those lines. I've had no fumbling problems.

Only glitch I've encountered was when I was kicking an extra point and right as my place holder got down in his position, the kicker walked back like he normally does, but instead, he too got down in the place holder position. The long snapper then snapped it to the kicker instead of the holder, but the kicker didn't catch the ball, as soon as he stood up he performed his kick motion. No kick was made, and if the kicker would have kicked a ball there, it would've hit the press box. That's the direction he was facing. Nothing a patch won't fix though. I wouldn't worry too much about it.
 

ClydeLee

New member
Joined:
Jun 29, 2010
Posts:
14,829
Liked Posts:
4,113
Location:
The OP
Never said they weren't relevant.

I said there are more relevant teams.

Yes you did, you just said the word relevant teams, not more relevant. Which means the others are not relevant in your sentence. Although it really doesn't matter as long as they have that create a school thing from 10 because most FCS schools of merit and Illinois ones like ISU, SIU, ESU were on there made for you to download and add to your list.

Plus some people hate the majority of big schools and hardly have their schools set up like they should be with stadiums or mascots or logical player rankings. NIU at least this year for example has their stadium right again. Somehow it was fine on the PS2 version then they altered it incorrectly next gen until now, plus they still leave out the mascot but I didn't check the rankings of players this season but last season all the player rankings were solely based on grade which had mid 80 rankings to kids who never even played the previous years and players who were great the years before despite being sophomores were listed as low 70s. They don't care about no BCS enough to merit it.(in the past at least)

I don't think I'm going to get it, I hope 2K sports makes a college game next year I believe they say the college football monopoly contract ends this year with EA although the NFL one has a year or 2 left.
 
Last edited:

tbo41fan

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
Apr 26, 2010
Posts:
15,922
Liked Posts:
2,701
Location:
Chicago, IL
My favorite teams
  1. Chicago Cubs
  1. Chicago Fire
  1. Chicago Bulls
  1. Chicago Bears
  1. Chicago Blackhawks
  1. Arizona Wildcats
As long as Arizona is in it, im ok with it
 

Lefty

New member
Joined:
Apr 19, 2010
Posts:
2,241
Liked Posts:
780
Some of the glitches and miscues in this game are unacceptable: PAT and field goal camera glitches, the PA bootleg hand-off glitch, inability to make assignment audibles on defense during a hurry-up occasionally, the game shipping with a new add-on not working at all prompting annoying pop-ups every time you enter or exit a game, all things that should have been easily caught during testing; while others are more forgivable: instead of telling you that using the right stick to gain extra yardage will increase fumbles, they leave you to figure it out on your own, and the option-pitch issues can be attributed to this being their first year with a new locomotion engine; and others are the usual EA head-scratchers: the CPU is still unstoppable on any difficulty setting in the 4th quarter, the CPU AI seemingly never makes use of the squib kick, this being the first year the squib kick is available on next-gen systems, ridiculous morphing by defenders for interceptions and swats, some on-field injuries not popping up or cuing commentary until a few plays later (if at all), a carbon-copy Road to Glory mode with literally ZERO improvements or additions and ridiculously stale commentary by a broadcast team less Lee Corso (who somehow still manages to make his pre-game picks if you review the matchup before a game).

But really, all of this is par for the course for EA, and in the end this will be a game you will lament not having once college football season rolls around, as the graphics indeed have received a boost, the new recruiting system is, well, new, to say the least, and they don't seem to have fucked up OD's that bad.

In my opinion, EA has bought themselves one more year of this "well, there are these gloriously unacceptable ****-ups but we didn't mess up the other stuff too bad" cycle, so pick it up this year and do the same thing next year: wait until the game drops, read reviews/rent/borrow from a buddy and then decide.
 

Lefty

New member
Joined:
Apr 19, 2010
Posts:
2,241
Liked Posts:
780
Oh yeah, and remember Option Dash, Tug of War and those little minigames? You know, they were fun to screw around with and get a feel for the game while waiting for rosters to come out, get polished, and so on. Remember those? Yeah, they're gone, probably only to be re-packaged next year as "new" or this year as DLC that you have to pay out the ass for.
 

USCChiFan

Crow's Nest
Donator
Joined:
Apr 16, 2010
Posts:
8,003
Liked Posts:
1,105
Location:
Behind you
So you're saying that it has it's flaws like every year but it's still worth it?
 

Lefty

New member
Joined:
Apr 19, 2010
Posts:
2,241
Liked Posts:
780
So you're saying that it has it's flaws like every year but it's still worth it?

To put it simply: yes. Every yearly sim from EA has it's glaring flaws (some of them game-breaking but more often than not they are "c'mon, EA" type of stuff) along with understandable issues, individual hit-or-miss type of stuff and marginal improvements.

This has been the modus operandi for EA (especially NCAA) for awhile now: add/remove components seemingly at will from year to year, usually lagging behind in removing modes/features that no one is interested in (Mascot games, one-button mode) and adding/upgrading/keeping ones fans do show interest in (squib kicks, Road to Glory, Option Dash and the like); create unacceptable-but-not-game-breaking glitches (this sounds like a contradiction in terms, but the "unacceptable" part stems from many of these glitches being discovered in the first few hours of gameplay, meaning they should have been caught during testing); tweak the graphics and experience by adding new shaders, increasing crowd reactions (which just means they turned the default volume on the crowd FX up) and add a few new animations (sideline grabs, stumbling QB's, etc.); make a few marginal enhancements to the gameplay (draws, pitches and screens aren't completely useless anymore, and the new locomotion engine makes for improved running and tackling, but it's not perfect); let some features ferment (the broadcast and soundtrack); package, repeat.

The game isn't bad by any means, but a realistic view of it yields just NCAA 10 with some freshly-polished areas and some new nicks and scratches in others. It's a classic, "if you liked last year's title you'll like this year's edition." This doesn't make for any decidedly bad games, necessarily, but the "kinda wash, kinda dirty, kinda wash, kinda dirty" cycle is getting old.
 

ClydeLee

New member
Joined:
Jun 29, 2010
Posts:
14,829
Liked Posts:
4,113
Location:
The OP
I'm saying it isn't worth it if your not a fan of the BCS league schools or power houses because some of the little conferences aren't given much dedication. The one thing at least they do very well for every school is stadiums, now over the past 2 seasons only though.

Plus I've always thought the skip 1 year philosophy is very good to go by. I had 10 so I'll pass on 11 because year to year they are always too similar at least every 2 years there's several updates and changing on issues. Graphically it's always going to have to change some for the perceptual better but that shouldn't even really be including in asking if it's worth it year to year.
 

USCChiFan

Crow's Nest
Donator
Joined:
Apr 16, 2010
Posts:
8,003
Liked Posts:
1,105
Location:
Behind you
Lefty alone has convinced me that NCAA is worth buying :)
I'll probably get it tomorrow. Also, Lefty which system do you play NCAA 11 on: XBOX 360 or PS3
 
Top