Ha I know people love the Show but I just don't think its that good. At the very least its no better than MVP baseball 2003, that in and of itself is sad.
We are 8 years later and it should just be a lot better. Is it better than 2K? Well yeah. Even though personally I think the game play of 2K is pretty good just the sim system and the bugs make it bad. MLB 2K9 I thought was a fantastic game online. It was smooth and if you knew how to avoid the OF bugs it played really well.
And I knew how to avoid them since I went about 120-6 over a week online, too bad that was my last positive experience in dealing with 2K sports.
But back to The Show I just don't think its nearly as good as people make it out to be. It's just considered good because the competition is well terrible.