Should we trade for a hitter or a pitcher?

Got teeth? Keith doesn't. · Jul 9, 2010

So, what is it? I think either or both would be good. What if Hudson sucks it up? And if Beckham can turn it around soon, that is basically like adding another bat. I'd say we should add another arm.

Lefty · Jul 9, 2010

No, you don't add anything to this team at this point, at least not through a trade. If you want to call some guys up to see what they have, fine, but with Peavy down there is little point to sacrificing the entire farm system to bring in someone of note.

DMelt36 · Jul 9, 2010

If we're going to get one, go for an arm. Pitching is what wins championships.

GrinderBall41 · Jul 9, 2010

I would like to add a hitter, but i would really hate to deplete our already thin farm system in a year where we really dont have a chance at a championship

If we can add a good long-term piece, i might feel differently

Lefty · Jul 9, 2010

GrinderBall41 said:
I would like to add a hitter, but i would really hate to deplete our already thin farm system in a year where we really dont have a chance at a championship

If we can add a good long-term piece, i might feel differently

Exactly, it depends on what is available. A "win now" type of player that is at or near the downside of his career? No thanks. An young MLB-ready prospect/current contributor? We'll talk.

hsvj60 · Jul 10, 2010

if we went after a player I would like a 3b LH .300+ hitter then we could send Vayan back down because for this kid to truly develop he must play everyday. Teahballs is not the answer and Vizquel can't do it everyday anymore. I know Jones has been hitting the last few games but I would still like to trade/release him and bring up DeAza as well and as far as pitching you boys are going to love Hudson the kid has what it takes to play in the show ya'll remember I said it about this kid and these moves might not cost us much at all...