Take 'em or Trash 'em: CUBS Edition

[Uman85]

Saw this on ESPNChicago today and thought it'd be a fun game to do on the board here.

Check it out: Take 'Em or Trash 'Em: 2011 Chicago Cubs - ESPN Chicago

 

[daddies3angels]

Hill= TRASH
Soto= keep (not to many good C in league)
Pena= TRASH (get Fielder)
Barney= keep (as utitlity IF)
Castro=keep
A-Ram=KEEP (wont find better 3B in FA or trade)
Baker=keep (good utility player)
DeWitt=Trash (enough said)
LeMahieu=keep
LaHair=keep
Soriano=trash
Byrd=trash (overrated)
Campana= keep
Colvin=keep
Johnson= Keep(good 4th OF)
Montanez=trash
Garza= keep
Dempster= trash (like to get younger in SP)
Wells= trash (hasnt done anything in 2 years)
Z=trash
Marmol= keep (value to low to trade)
Marshall= keep
Carpenter = keep
Grabow= trash
Lopez=trash
Mateo= keep
Ortiz=trash
Russell= keep
Shark = keep
Coleman = keep
Cashner = keep
Wood = keep
Quade = TRASH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[inactiveuser1]

Keep shark?

 

[marky mark]

Soriano=trash

Marmol= keep (value to low to trade)

So Marmol has to low of value to trade but Soriano is do-able????

 

[waldo7239117]

Hill= TRASH
Soto= keep (not to many good C in league)
Pena= Keep (get Fielder)
Barney= keep (as utitlity IF)
Castro=keep
A-Ram=Trash (wont find better 3B in FA or trade)
Baker=Trash (good utility player)
DeWitt=Trash (enough said)
LeMahieu=keep
LaHair=Trash
Soriano=trash
Byrd=trash (overrated)
Campana= keep
Colvin=keep
Johnson= Trash(good 4th OF)
Montanez=trash
Garza= keep
Dempster= Keep (like to get younger in SP)
Wells= Keep (hasnt done anything in 2 years)
Z=trash
Marmol= keep (value to low to trade)
Marshall= keep
Carpenter = keep
Grabow= trash
Lopez=trash
Mateo= Trash
Ortiz=trash
Russell= keep
Shark = keep
Coleman = keep
Cashner = keep
Wood = keep
Quade = TRASH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!

 

[waldo7239117]

So Marmol has to low of value to trade but Soriano is do-able????

Releaseable. But I think if Cubs pay majorty of contract, they can trade him to the AL to be a DH. 2 spots could be Boston or Yankees. Depending on what Ortiz does, one may need a DH.

 

[waldo7239117]

Keep shark?

Yeah. They have too. As they need RP and Samardzija wasn't too bad this year.

 

[inactiveuser1]

Yeah. They have too. As they need RP and Samardzija wasn't too bad this year.

Meh, they could do better but I guess if they have no other choice, then they should keep him

 

[daddies3angels]

Keep shark?

Guy had under 3 ERA this year. Still young power arm. Yes you keep

 

[daddies3angels]

So Marmol has to low of value to trade but Soriano is do-able????

Soriano has no value cause of contract. Marmol contract is tradeable BUT right now his market is way down cause of bad year.

 

[Mr. Cub]

Hill= TRASH
Soto= keep
Pena= If we don't get Prince or the Machine= keep
Barney= keep
Castro=keep
A-Ram=KEEP (Our best run producer by far)
Baker= Whatever
DeWitt= Whatever works
LeMahieu=keep (He's young)
LaHair=keep (Showed some promise)
Soriano= Either. He still has power but if we could get something we should take.
Byrd=Keep (Heart & Hustle right here)
Campana= keep (Burner)
Colvin= Ehh after this season I would say who cares
Johnson= Keep (Read: Byrd)
Montanez=trash
Garza= keep Our best P by far.
Dempster= Either. His prime I believe has passed us by.
Wells= Keep (Wait and see if he can build on the way he finished this season)
Z= I would keep if we get a new no BS manager.
Marmol= keep until he starts blowing games and then can his ass.
Marshall= keep
Carpenter = keep
Grabow= trash
Lopez= Not a bad spot starter.
Mateo= keep
Ortiz=trash
Russell= keep
Shark = keep
Coleman = Who knows with this cat.
Cashner = keep
Wood = keep
Quade = We need a new manager for sure. Sorry Mike.