Top 5 players at every position from 2000-2020 (UPDATED w/ more positions and Madden rating!)

[sportinorton18]

QB :
1. Jay Cutler 87
2. Mitchell Trubisky 77
3. Kyle Orton 76
4. Josh McCown 83
5. Brian Griese 81

RB :
1. Matt Forte 95
2. Thomas Jones 88
3. David Montgomery 82
4. Jordan Howard 86
5. Anthony Thomas 84

FB :
1. Jason McKie 84
2. Tyler Clutts 66
3. Daimon Shelton 78
4. Tony Fiammetta 72
5. Bryan Johnson 86

WR :
1. Brandon Marshall 96
2. Allen Robinson 90
3. Alshon Jeffery 91
4. Marty Booker 90
5. Marcus Robinson 93

SWR :
1. Earl Bennett 77
2. Anthony Miller 76
3. Rashied Davis 74
4. Marquess Wilson 73
5. Josh Bellamy 75

TE :
1. Martellus Bennett 90
2. Greg Olsen 86
3. Desmond Clark 84
4. Trey Burton 87
5. Zach Miller 86

LT :
1. John Tait 91
2. Blake Brockermeyer 86
3. Charles Leno 83
4. Jermon Bushrod 86
5. John St. Clair 75

LG :
1. Ruben Brown 92
2. Matt Slauson 91
3. Josh Sitton 89
4. Rex Tucker 89
5. James Daniels 78

C :
1. Olin Kreutz 98
2. Cody Whitehair 86
3. Roberto Garza 80
4. James Daniels 76
5. Brian De La Puente 83

RG :
1. Kyle Long 88
2. Roberto Garza 85
3. Chris Villarrial 81
4. Lance Louis 72
5. Chris Spencer 77

RT :
1. James Williams 89
2. Fred Miller 88
3. John Tait 89
4. Bobbie Massie 75
5. Jordan Mills 74

 

[sportinorton18]

4-3 LE :
1. Adewale Ogunleye 91
2. Isreal Idonije 82
3. Willie Young 80
4. Corey Wootton 78
5. Bryan Robinson 83

4-3 RE :
1. Julius Peppers 97
2. Alex Brown 88
3. Phillip Daniels 89
4. Mark Anderson 84
5. Shea McClellin 76

3-4 LE :
1. Akiem Hicks 88
2. Roy Robertson-Harris 73
3. Brent Urban 75
4. Nicholas Williams 71
5. Cornelius Washington 69

3-4 RE :
1. Mitch Unrein 80
2. Bilal Nichols 74
3. Mario Edwards Jr. 72
4. Jarvis Jenkins 72
5. Jonathan Bullard 74

4-3 DT :
1. Tommie Harris 97
2. Ted Washington 89
3. Keith Traylor 90
4. Henry Melton 90
5. Stephen Paea 86

3-4 DT :
1. Eddie Goldman 85
2. Bilal Nichols 79
3. John Jenkins 72
4. Bruce Gaston 71
5. C.J. Wilson 71

4-3 SLB :
1. Roosevelt Colvin 90
2. Pisa Tinoisamoa 78
3. Nick Roach 75
4. Hunter Hillenmeyer 79
5. James Anderson 82

3-4 LOLB :
1. Khalil Mack 99
2. Pernell McPhee 91
3. Leonard Floyd 77
4. Aaron Lynch 76
5. Sam Acho 78

4-3 MLB :
1. Brian Urlacher 99
2. Barry Minter 89
3. D.J. Williams 80
4. Hunter Hillenmeyer 71
5. Jon Bostic 75

3-4 MLB :
1. Roquan Smith 86
2. Jerrell Freeman 88
3. Danny Trevathan 85
4. Nick Kwiatkoski 78
5. Christian Jones 72

4-3 WLB :
1. Lance Briggs 96
2. Warrick Holdman 86
3. Jamar Williams 73
4. Geno Hayes 74
5. Brian Iwuh 65

3-4 ROLB :
1. Leonard Floyd 79
2. Willie Young 82
3. Sam Acho 78
4. Robert Quinn 76
5. Isaiah Irving 67

CB :
1. Charles Tillman 95
2. Kyle Fuller 89
3. Tim Jennings 90
4. Nathan Vasher 92
5. R.W. McQuarters 86

NCB :
1. Bryce Callahan 81
2. Ricky Manning Jr. 86
3. D.J. Moore 74
4. Kelvin Hayden 76
5. Cre'von LeBlanc 75

FS :
1. Mike Brown 91
2. Eddie Jackson 91
3. Chris Harris 88
4. Shawn Wooden 86
5. Danieal Manning 84

SS :
1. Mike Brown 92
2. Tony Parrish 84
3. Adrian Amos 90
4. Chris Harris 81
5. Major Wright 81

 

[sportinorton18]

K :
1. Robbie Gould 95
2. Cairo Santos 73
3. Paul Edinger 90
4. Eddy Pineiro 72
5. Connor Barth 75

P :
1. Brad Maynard 95
2. Pat O'Donnell 80
3. Adam Podlesh 78
4. Louie Aguiar 76
5. Brent Bartholomew N/A

KR :
1. Devin Hester 81
2. Cordarrelle Patterson 78
3. Danieal Manning 84
4. Jerry Azumah 83
5. Johnny Knox 79

PR :
1. Devin Hester 81
2. Tarik Cohen 85
3. Earl Bennett 77
4. R.W. McQuarters 86
5. Marc Mariani 69

ST :
1. Brendan Ayanbadejo 68
2. Sherrick McManis 69
3. Corey Graham 70
4. Tim Shaw 57
5. Larry Wigham 62

3DRB :
1. Matt Forte 93
2. Tarik Cohen 85
3. Benny Cunningham 75
4. Adrian Peterson 77
5. Chester Taylor 79

LS :
1. Patrick Mannelly 70
2. Patrick Scales 42
3. Thomas Gafford 69
4. Andrew DePaola 62
5. Jeremy Cain 61

 

[TheWinman]

Too many good laughs to mention them all

 

[ThatGuyRyan]

Shelton was a beast of a FB

 

[MDB111™]

Rex Grossman took the Bears to the Superbowl. For the first 8 weeks he was MVP worthy. Yes the wheels came all the way off but he is a good part of the reason we were there. To put either Orton, McCown or Griese ahead of him is egregious.


There, I said it.
Sex Cannon

 

[Leomaz]

Pernell McPhee?
Nope

 

[Bearin' Down]

QB:
1. Jay Cutler
2. Mitchell Trubisky
3. Kyle Orton
4. Josh McCown
5. Brian Griese

RB:
1. Matt Forte
2. Thomas Jones
3. David Montgomery
4. Jordan Howard
5. Anthony Thomas

FB:
1. Jason McKie
2. Tyler Clutts
3. Daimon Shelton
4. Tony Fiammetta
5. Bryan Johnson

WR:
1. Brandon Marshall
2. Alshon Jeffery
3. Marty Booker
4. Allen Robinson
5. Marcus Robinson

TE:
1. Martellus Bennett
2. Greg Olsen
3. Zach Miller
4. Desmond Clark
5. Cole Kmet

LT:
1. John Tait
2. Blake Brockermeyer
3. Charles Leno
4. Jermon Bushrod
5. John St. Clair

LG:
1. Matt Slauson
2. Ruben Brown
3. Josh Sitton
4. Rex Tucker
5. James Daniels

C:
1. Olin Kreutz
2. Cody Whitehair
3. James Daniels
4. Roberto Garza
5. Casey Weigmann

RG:
1. Kyle Long
2. Roberto Garza
3. Chris Villarrial
4. Lance Louis
5. Chris Spencer

RT:
1. James Williams
2. Fred Miller
3. John Tait
4. Bobbie Massie
5. Jordan Mills

Your WRs have serious issues. Allen Robinson is certainly more productive than Marty Booker. I know Booker performed for 2 years, but Allen has put up better numbers over those same 2 plus a better third. He should also be above Jeffery.

Greg Olsen is clearly the best TE. The guy is still in the league on a playoff roster. Trey Burton was better than Zach Miller.

 

[bamainatlanta]

Allen is #2 only to Marshall.

 

[sportinorton18]

Updated

 

[Bort]

Tony Parrish getting some serious disrespect for being ranked behind Adrian Amos

 

[Milky]

Your WRs have serious issues. Allen Robinson is certainly more productive than Marty Booker. I know Booker performed for 2 years, but Allen has put up better numbers over those same 2 plus a better third. He should also be above Jeffery.

Greg Olsen is clearly the best TE. The guy is still in the league on a playoff roster. Trey Burton was better than Zach Miller.

Shit.… Jimmy Graham belongs on the list before either of them and certainly before Kmet and that’s coming from someone who likes Kmet and hates how soft JG plays. But he is at least a consistent viable red zone target.

 

[msadows]

Rex Grossman took the Bears to the Superbowl. For the first 8 weeks he was MVP worthy. Yes the wheels came all the way off but he is a good part of the reason we were there. To put either Orton, McCown or Griese ahead of him is egregious.


There, I said it.
Sex Cannon

Yep, sexy rexy is prob the 3rd best QB in the last 20 years for this bears team. Kyle Orton wasn't even really good for this team, he started playing well when he went to the broncos in the cutler trade, before that he was a shell shocked nfl game manager.

 

[fx1718]

Too many good laughs to mention them all

Like Bennett over Olsen? Lol

 

[msadows]

Like Bennett over Olsen? Lol

I don't have an issue with that one, olsen didn't really become a beast until we traded him away. Bennett was a borderline top 5 TE in the league during his first couple years here.

 

[fx1718]

I don't have an issue with that one, olsen didn't really become a beast until we traded him away. Bennett was a borderline top 5 TE in the league during his first couple years here.

in 2014 sure. Otherwise no.

 

[msadows]

in 2014 sure. Otherwise no.

Nah, Bennett was def. a better TE on the bears than olsen was. Olsen was obviously the better TE eventually, because he came into his prime off the bears, while bennett did so on the bears. This is all about bears players tho.....Bennett outgained olsen in yardage and catches in 3 years than what olsen did in 4 here....that makes him better.

 

[Kaufman20Embalm]

Shaw over Ayanbadejo? Are you crazy?

 

[Unannounced Fart]

For ST, I'd put Ayanbadejo and McManis at #1 and 2... and add Corey Graham at #3 at worst.. possibly #2.

 

[MDB111™]

Stil LOLing at McCown, Orton and Griese on this list.