MJ, Wilt, Magic, and Kareem.
MJ is still considered the greatest of all-time. 6 time Finals MVP. 6-0 Finals record, set numerous NBA Finals records, scoring records as well. 5 time MVP.
Wilt set numerous records, one of which will never be broken (100 points). Never really much of a winner in a sense as he only won NBA title in his career. Books you read about him make him seem like he was more concerned with records than winning.
Magic went to the Finals 9 out of his 12 seasons in the NBA. He has 3 Finals MVPs and 3 Regular Season MVPs. Magic benefited from being on a stacked Lakers team (Kareem and Worthy and worthy players Bryon Scott and Michael Cooper to add)
Kareem dominated the game in the 1970's and due to the stacked roster of the Lakers was able to play for 20 NBA seasons. He won 6 MVPs and 2 Finals MVPs. Appeared in 10 NBA Finals, winning 6 of them.
------------
LeBron James has played as long as Magic Johnson at this point and surpassed him in playoff minutes and games this season. He has less Finals appearances than Magic (but has been on way worse teams).. He has appeared in 7 NBA Finals in 12 years, but his teams have only won 2 of them. He has won 4 MVPs and 2 Finals MVPs.
If anyone gets kicked off, I'd say its Magic for LeBron. Similar players in a way as well.