Alfonso Soriano retires

[brett05]

So a Cub player with a solid MLB career retires and it turns into a White Sox comparison thread.

I think you can blame cub fans on that one

 

[Parade_Rain]

He's not better than konerko and he is not going to make it. Dunn might be better and he ain't making it

Great player but not hall of fame worthy

I'd politely ask you research the stats on Dunn vs Sori. Even with his bad years in Chicago he still was the better player.

If Sori batted middle of the order he'd lose his speed. He'd have more homers but more whiffs as well and less walks and more than likely a lower on base as well. Paulie would probably still edge him out.

Three great players period. Just not making the hall let alone first ballot worthy

I think you can blame cub fans on that one

Oh really?

 

[brett05]

Oh really?

Check post number three

 

[Parade_Rain]

Check post number three

Yeah. He was spot on. It didn't require in depth analysis or any mention of Adam Dunn either. There is a Hall of Very Good and no matter how one slices it, that's where he fits.

 

[brett05]

Yeah. He was spot on. It didn't require in depth analysis or any mention of Adam Dunn either. There is a Hall of Very Good and no matter how one slices it, that's where he fits.

Or any mention of konerko.

Like you said he was a great player. Just not hall worthy and certainly not first ballot worthy