You don't get it. He's a POS hitter. He has hit .262/.288/.384 over the last three seasons. His peak season is a paltry .310 wOBA season. If he was a good hitter, or even average, I could see that argument being made. But he's just a bad hitter. At best, his line could jump to about .270/.305/.400 or so. To go along with his, what I've heard it quoted as, bad baseball instincts, he's just not a number two hitter. And to use the reasoning, "hitting in front of those hitters=better pitches" can work on any hitter, so why not on a hitter that isn't god-awful at hitting?