I’ll take his and your word for it. I’m not saying you’re wrong, but if that doesn’t translate on the field, which it hasn’t over the last several years, what does it matter that the tape is kind to him?
What happens is fans get caught up in a narrative, in the mentally it's hard to break free from that narrative.
In this case we have The narrative of him not being the guy in Cincinnati and the disappointment from that, and because of that it has followed him around.
meanwhile no one wants to take a look at the more complex things of why someone succeeds or fails.
I will give you a case in point:
Men's trubisky was obviously not the right quarterback because he read defenses way too slowly and couldn't barely get past his first read or two. As such, either him or Matt nagy get the blame for him failing.
However, what is lost on people with regards to the offense overall, is that Cody white hair was the center for the longest time and was playing out of the position he made the pro Bowl in, left guard. On top of it, thanks to the comparison when Sam Mustapher took over, we now know white hair have a serious issue with the calls at the line the center must make.
Indeed part of the reason our offensive line looked so bad wasn't from a lack of talents but because Cody was having a lineman blocked the wrong people and making the wrong calls at the line.
When you had someone who knew how to make the right calls at the line in Sam, suddenly the O line improved dramatically.
that's what I mean by digging deeper but right now most people would just say casually that are offensive line sucks because they haven't invested the time or energy to understand it.
Basically it's the lazy way out.
I think the same thing is happening with Dalton here.
and a lot of the resistance to the fact that Dalton really is an okay quarterback, more falls along the lines of fans asking the people saying such to not make them think hard and to do things when they already have their lazily comfortable opinion that they don't want to change it this time. Basically it's the classic "don't make me do stuff" excuse.