Bust, Serviceable, Good, Elite?

[Midwaymonster75]

OK 6 QBs 4 grades lets separate the men from the boys so we can look back in 3 years and call out the clowns claiming to have known who would and wouldnt bust. We have 5 choices and like the heading says put the letter grades of B, S, G, E next to the qbs name.

Caleb Williams E
Drake Maye G
Micheal Penix. B
JJ McCarthy S
Jayden Daniels E
Bo Nix S

 

[Anytime23]

STEP ASIDE CITIZENS

I'LL GO FIRST

Caleb Williams G(Great)
Drake Maye E
Micheal Penix. S
JJ McCarthy S
Jayden Daniels S
Bo Nix B

 

[DaaBears]

Caleb Williams S
Drake Maye S
Michael Penix E
JJ McCarthy B
Jayden Daniels S
Bo Nix B

 

[Toast88]

Caleb Williams - Good

Everyone else - Bust

 

[Toast88]

A guy named Penix is not going to be a good NFL quarterback. Come on, guys. Did you learn nothing from Curtis Enis?

 

[dabears70]

I'll tell you when i see who drafts them cause if they go to any Bears type organization then it won't be too good of a outcome for them.

 

[msadows]

Caleb Williams Bust
Drake Maye Bust
Micheal Penix. Bust
JJ McCarthy Bust
Jayden Daniels Bust
Bo Nix Bust
Spencer Rattler Elite

 

[Midwaymonster75]

Just take a shot. Its not that serious. Live a little, jeesh!

 

[Hawkeye OG]

Caleb Williams Good
Drake Maye Bust
Micheal Penix. Bust
JJ McCarthy Serviceable
Jayden Daniels good
Bo Nix bust

 

[Anytime23]

I'll tell you when i see who drafts them cause if they go to any Bears type organization then it won't be too good of a outcome for them.

Typical Dongbears.

 

[greg23]

When penix and Nix go in round 2 and are meh in the nfl....are they busts?

 

[wklink]

Everyone except the player picked by the Bears will be an Elite QB.

The one Chicago picks will be a solid bust.

 

[Bearly]

Caleb Williams E
Drake Maye E
Micheal Penix. S
JJ McCarthy G
Jayden Daniels S
Bo Nix B

This is an early take on these guys and not reflective of where they end up after 3 years. McCarthy might be the safest QB pick in this draft and 3rd taken due to that. I suspect that he'll throw and interview well and be the most NFL ready if taken for a balanced attack. I also think Williams will be the consensus 1st taken by draft day just because the ceiling is so high and he'll test through the roof. I gave Maye a high grade simply due to play style and my bias toward full field pocket passers. Williams obviously has the highest ceiling but it may take him longer to learn to not bail early and he's got that (maybe deserved) diva factor which can but doesn't always stunt growth. That said, he's smart and a playmaker.

 

[Milky]

Caleb Williams G
Drake Maye G
Micheal Penix. B
JJ McCarthy S
Jayden Daniels G
Bo Nix B

 

[Anytime23]

When penix and Nix go in round 2 and are meh in the nfl....are they busts?

 

[HeHateMe]

View attachment 32810

Could it be any more obvious?

 

[Texas Bear Fan]

Caleb Williams G
Drake Maye G
Micheal Penix. S
JJ McCarthy B
Jayden Daniels B
Bo Nix S

 

[Bust]

I'll tell you when i see who drafts them cause if they go to any Bears type organization then it won't be too good of a outcome for them.

#fakenews

 

[sevvy]

This is hard to say without knowing where they're going. But with all things being equal...

Caleb Williams - Elite
Drake Maye - Good
Michael Penix Jr. - Serviceable
JJ McCarthey - Bust
Jayden Daniels - Serviceable
Bo Nix - Bust

 

[BNB]

Odds are, at least 3 of these guys will be busts.