You know if you think about it, the Campbell contract was a loser team contract - and what I mean by that is - your basic vast overpayment to attract a guy there -- iirc too it was made during the prior ownership group of the team's time in charge -what I mean by that is not Dale Tallon this that or the other thing -but more along the lines of I don't know what the state of the salary cap was vis a vis the Hawks at the time Campbell was signed here - although knowing the way Pulford worked ... it would be plausible that the salary cap floor might have been a factor..
The Campbell contract is great for teams not at the floor -and for better or worse, that is what he sold himself to - teams near the floor when he signed it- he did a good job of picking out a team on the rise (although I don't recall if Kane was drafted at the time he came here or not ... in other words; Kane would have proved nothing at that point irregardless of if he was drafted by the team or not - so you couldn't really pick that the team was a championship threat as far out as to when he signed.
So in effect, I don't know that this is anti-Campbell or anti-anything - in that Campbell got lucky, he got a championship ring, and a big long term payday at the same time, all while not being a Norris Trophy candidate ever. The plain fact of the matter is, is that Brian Campbell is too one dimensional to ever have been in that sort of discussion (Norris Trophy candidate).