Edge Defender Rankings - Guess who is No 1

remydat

CCS Hall of Fame
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '19
Joined:
Sep 15, 2012
Posts:
60,989
Liked Posts:
39,293
I watch the games and sack numbers aside, I haven't seen the same guy I saw in 18. That version of Mack was consistently destroying double and triple teams. The Mack I've seen recently I've watched lose a lot of 1 on 1s....hell, seen him getting 1 on 1 blocked by a TE. Now, he's still a great player and has probably been banged up the past couple of seasons...but it goes way beyond his sack numbers. He just doesn't look like the same otherworldly player. PFF rankings are nice and all, but the eye test shows a diminished player than his 18 self. It also seems like his motor was higher and more consistent in 18. Runs a bit hot/cold lately.

2018 Mack was a DPOY and just a tick below Aaron Donald. 2020 Mack is the best edge player in the NFL but the gap between him and Donald has widened.

It is the difference between being a generational talent ie Donald vs simply being one of the top players at your position. Both versions of Mack are still worth the money IMO.
 

dabears70

Well-known member
Joined:
Dec 31, 2013
Posts:
35,129
Liked Posts:
10,885
Location:
Orlando
My favorite teams
  1. New York Mets
  1. New York Knicks
  1. Chicago Bears
  1. New York Rangers
  1. Syracuse Orange
Probably because he is 31 and was injured and missed most of the season last year.
Which is why i said he's been underrated his entire career and didn't anything about last year.
 

Hutch1975

Active member
Joined:
Oct 2, 2020
Posts:
405
Liked Posts:
194
My favorite teams
  1. Milwaukee Brewers
  1. Chicago Bulls
  1. Chicago Bears
  1. Edmonton Oilers
  1. Brigham Young Cougars
They have Hicks at #15 among interior linemen, and noted he had some pretty high pass-rush grades, too.

To me, it's about getting the pressure. Mack and Hicks don't have to get the sack. It could be a teammate that gets the sack. Or maybe the QB, sensing they're close to his personal space, ends up passing without the best of reads.
 

PrideisBears

Jordan Sigler’s editor
Staff member
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '21
Joined:
Jun 20, 2010
Posts:
39,224
Liked Posts:
28,884
Location:
In the mod forum planning your ban
They have Hicks at #15 among interior linemen, and noted he had some pretty high pass-rush grades, too.

To me, it's about getting the pressure. Mack and Hicks don't have to get the sack. It could be a teammate that gets the sack. Or maybe the QB, sensing they're close to his personal space, ends up passing without the best of reads.
Mack was getting behind the line but Pagano allowed a cushion on every single snap so if there was even a slightly competent QB back there, they saw the opening
 
Last edited:
Joined:
Sep 11, 2017
Posts:
39
Liked Posts:
50
You will see a night and day difference with our defense if our offense can consistently put up points, stay on the field longer than three plays, minimize turnovers, and yield better starting field position for them.

I can't imagine the lasting impact on your desire to consistently play lights out on D when you you lose to the Packers despite holding Aaron Rodgers to 10 points...

Those guys can still ball out... yes, they are older, but give them a few minutes to catch their breath collectively between series, an intelligent scheme, and above all else, faith that the offense can bail them out if they give up a big play, and they will return to 2018 form; or at least something close to it.
 

Nelly

Well-known member
Joined:
Mar 13, 2018
Posts:
7,187
Liked Posts:
8,332
You will see a night and day difference with our defense if our offense can consistently put up points, stay on the field longer than three plays, minimize turnovers, and yield better starting field position for them.

I can't imagine the lasting impact on your desire to consistently play lights out on D when you you lose to the Packers despite holding Aaron Rodgers to 10 points...

Those guys can still ball out... yes, they are older, but give them a few minutes to catch their breath collectively between series, an intelligent scheme, and above all else, faith that the offense can bail them out if they give up a big play, and they will return to 2018 form; or at least something close to it.
Yep. It's a lot harder to rush the passer when the opposing team is in position to hold onto a lead with the run game. You can't just break contain in pursuit of the QB all game long.
 

Enasic

Who are the brain police?
Joined:
Mar 17, 2014
Posts:
13,932
Liked Posts:
9,733
2018 Mack was a DPOY and just a tick below Aaron Donald. 2020 Mack is the best edge player in the NFL but the gap between him and Donald has widened.

It is the difference between being a generational talent ie Donald vs simply being one of the top players at your position. Both versions of Mack are still worth the money IMO.
So you’re saying Mack is the best edge player definitively because PFF says so or because of his PFF rankings and the eye test?
 

WindyCity

CCS Hall of Fame
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '19
Joined:
Dec 12, 2011
Posts:
30,816
Liked Posts:
35,414
No issues with Mack. We need a young, cheap, cost controlled running mate for him.
 

remydat

CCS Hall of Fame
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '19
Joined:
Sep 15, 2012
Posts:
60,989
Liked Posts:
39,293
Which is why i said he's been underrated his entire career and didn't anything about last year.

Underrated by whom? He was an All Pro 2 out of the last 3 years when he was healthy.
 

bamainatlanta

You wake him up, you keep him up
Staff member
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '22
Joined:
Aug 10, 2013
Posts:
37,332
Liked Posts:
34,540
Location:
Cumming
No issues with Mack. We need a young, cheap, cost controlled running mate for him.

Yep. And not an injured, expensive, old veteran like Quinn
 

remydat

CCS Hall of Fame
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '19
Joined:
Sep 15, 2012
Posts:
60,989
Liked Posts:
39,293
So you’re saying Mack is the best edge player definitively because PFF says so or because of his PFF rankings and the eye test?

Yes from what I can see Pagano was a huge reason for his lack of sacks. If you compare to TJ Watt for example, Watt is single blocked far more than Mack because the Steelers scheme for him to get one on ones.

He is clearly a top Edge player even if you dont eant to put him at one. That is the point.
 

remydat

CCS Hall of Fame
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '19
Joined:
Sep 15, 2012
Posts:
60,989
Liked Posts:
39,293
Yep. And not an injured, expensive, old veteran like Quinn

I may be in the minority but I think Quinn will be fine this year. His PRWR and double team % was higher than Floyd's. It is just one of those things where he was pretty unlucky in terms of finishing and again Pagano did not help him.
 

Pegger

President Stoopid
Joined:
Sep 18, 2012
Posts:
7,621
Liked Posts:
5,493
Location:
Communist Canada
I hate all the rankings articles that come out in this time of year. Just throwing out random opinions trying to generate clicks.
 

MikeDitkaPolishSausage

Well-known member
Joined:
Aug 12, 2013
Posts:
9,238
Liked Posts:
7,028
Location:
Black Rainbow’s Grandma’s house.
I may be in the minority but I think Quinn will be fine this year. His PRWR and double team % was higher than Floyd's. It is just one of those things where he was pretty unlucky in terms of finishing and again Pagano did not help him.
I think most Bears fans think Quinn needs to prove himself. At this point as a Chicago Bear he is a bust and a waste of money. The question is, what does his 2021 season have to look like to be worth that contract he signed?
 

bamainatlanta

You wake him up, you keep him up
Staff member
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '22
Joined:
Aug 10, 2013
Posts:
37,332
Liked Posts:
34,540
Location:
Cumming
I may be in the minority but I think Quinn will be fine this year. His PRWR and double team % was higher than Floyd's. It is just one of those things where he was pretty unlucky in terms of finishing and again Pagano did not help him.

I think he will be fine if his dead foot is healed. If not, give the reps to Attachou(?) & Gipson
 

dabears70

Well-known member
Joined:
Dec 31, 2013
Posts:
35,129
Liked Posts:
10,885
Location:
Orlando
My favorite teams
  1. New York Mets
  1. New York Knicks
  1. Chicago Bears
  1. New York Rangers
  1. Syracuse Orange
Yes from what I can see Pagano was a huge reason for his lack of sacks. If you compare to TJ Watt for example, Watt is single blocked far more than Mack because the Steelers scheme for him to get one on ones.

He is clearly a top Edge player even if you dont eant to put him at one. That is the point.
The Steelers probably blitz more than any other team, if not then it's real close, but the blitzing helps Watt and did help B.Dupree to get to the QB.
 

Enasic

Who are the brain police?
Joined:
Mar 17, 2014
Posts:
13,932
Liked Posts:
9,733
Yes from what I can see Pagano was a huge reason for his lack of sacks. If you compare to TJ Watt for example, Watt is single blocked far more than Mack because the Steelers scheme for him to get one on ones.

He is clearly a top Edge player even if you dont eant to put him at one. That is the point.
I think he is a top edge player…is he the best? I don’t know but he’s up there. We’re in agreement that he’s not the same player as he was in 18 but still elite overall
 

Top