Based on the skill level of his competition, I vote for Tillman vs. Megatron.
Megatron's stats per game: 7.625 receptions per game, 12.8 targets per game, 122.75 yards per game
On that night, Tillman held him to 3 rec for 34 yards 0 td (I can't find the number of targets but it's got to be at least 10 targets).... epic performance by Tillman on an epic receiver like Megatron.
I agree. Tillman should run away with this one. Both fantastic feats. If I have to choose, it has to be the megaton game. Megaton is amazing and to see him handled like that is impressive. The titans have to be so embarrassed at the 4 fumbles though. Hilarious.
TN was close, I was at that game. All around it was amazing, Tillman forced fumbles, touchdowns on defense, special teams, and Brandon Marshall made everybody look foolish with three touchdowns.
But Megatron is the best freak of a wide receiver we'll probably ever see, and shutting him down doesn't happen without playing a perfect game.