Did we already?? Maybe we should see how our FA pan out before we judge? I know alot want 12 mil/year FA but didn't happen this year. I'll take Houstons power and versatility over Michael Bennett, but that's just me.
We won!!! Lots of land mines out there that could have back fired, but we made a few strong moves outside of our team, and retained all the guys we needed to except Melton who were difference makers. We got two DE's for the best bargain price of any team. We got Mundy for free basically. And we cut ourselves free of a couple players that didn't seem to buy in. (Melton/Peppers)
You can look at FA however you want, but i don't think any team has a bounty like this.
Cutler, CB Jennings, CB Tillman, D.J.Williams, Lamar Houston, Willie Young, SS Mundy, OG Slauson, DT Ratliff, Return man- Hixon, DT Collins
Every single one of those guys could have played for someone else. They could have gone to their hometown. they could have gone back to their college town, to play for their favorite coach or with their best friend. they could have all walked.
Emery has astounded me with his ability to switch gears when needed, or to make the hard choices and retain.
Tillman says Tucker did a great job, so he must have some skill sets we don't see. We don't see what he means to his guys. Lets give it another year, I think Emery realized he could prepare us for versatility this year and make a decision on the defense next off-season. He is likely watching different defenses closely to see which direction he wants to go, and he probably has statistical basis for his decision. (analysis that may include the consequences of switching coordinators too frequently, even when transitioning a team needs a direction to work toward, and I think you see us moving to more principles of the 3-4)
Overhauling the defense straight to Phillips 3-4 would probably have handicapped us, but I think after moving Shea to LB and adding Houston we are closer than ever before.
Briggs/Young, Paea, Tillman, Bostic
are the guys who probably don't fit the 3-4 too well, and you see our investment in them is minimal after this season.