Miscommunication on Cobb's TD

bamainatlanta

You wake him up, you keep him up
Staff member
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '22
Joined:
Aug 10, 2013
Posts:
34,582
Liked Posts:
34,841
Location:
Cumming
David Haugh
In the Wake of the News
10:32 p.m. CST, December 29, 2013

Looking as devastated as every Bears fan felt early Sunday evening, safety Chris Conte slowly walked away from his locker declining comment on the biggest play of the season.

Conte's eyes were red and his head was down as he stared at the carpet.

"There was a little miscommunication on that final play," cornerback Tim Jennings said a few stalls away.

DAVID HAUGH
David Haugh
Bio | E-mail | Recent columns
RELATED
Bears' defense saves dumbest for last
D saves dumbest for last
Rodgers to Cobb TD pass finishes off Bears
Rodgers to Cobb TD pass finishes off Bears
VOTE: Trust Bears GM to revamp defense?
VOTE: Trust Bears GM to revamp defense?
Four downs: Fitting way to end season
VOTE: DO YOU WANT CUTLER BACK NEXT SEASON?
Bears fans, do you want Jay Cutler back next season?

Yes
No

Week 17 photos: Packers 33, Bears 28
Packers hand Bears gut-wrenching loss
See more stories »
MAPS
Soldier Field, 1410 Museum Campus Dr, Chicago, IL 60605

Chicagoans, we have a nomination for Biggest Understatement of 2013.

A Bears season once packed with playoff promise ended suddenly amid empty despair. A 33-28 loss to the Packers made the Bears 8-8; good enough at times to tease us into thinking anything was possible but still bad enough to deserve your skepticism.

"I don't know what to say," linebacker James Anderson said in a somber locker room.

In living rooms and barrooms around Chicagoland, they could relate.

On a windy, wintry December day, Chicago suffered through one of the coldest endings to a Bears game in several seasons no matter what the thermometer said. The worst defense in Bears history cemented its legacy by blowing a late fourth-quarter lead with the NFC North title on the line.

The Packers beat the Bears and coach Marc Trestman lost the benefit of the doubt heading into an offseason of uncertainty that really began with 46 seconds left. The Packers faced fourth-and-8 at the Bears' 48 — fourth-and-the-season, if you will. Bears defensive coordinator Mel Tucker dialed up a blitz to pressure Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers.

"They brought the house," Rodgers said.

Imagine how big Rodgers' eyes got when he saw nobody home to defend Randall Cobb.

"The thinking was we could sit back in zone and give them the opportunity to make a play or force them to rush a throw," Trestman explained later.

Problem is, not everybody in the Bears secondary was thinking the same thing. Cornerbacks Zack Bowman and Jennings both referred to running a "zone blitz." But nickel back Isaiah Frey, who rushed Rodgers, mentioned the Bears were in man coverage behind him. Trestman insisted the same, confirming the muddled message.

"It was man coverage," Trestman said. "If a quarterback breaks contain in a zero blitz (against man coverage) like that, it leaves a lot of field. You're leaving the back end one-on-one."

In this case, it produced one-on-none. Cobb, seeing Conte's feet plant as if to defend the flat area instead of the Packers receiver in front of him, decided to convert a hook route into something deeper. Rodgers bought himself an extra second to throw by scrambling left as fullback John Kuhn disrupted Julius Peppers' rushing lane. The ball landed perfectly in Cobb's hands for a touchdown that "will be running on the highlight reel for the rest of my time on this earth," Packers coach Mike McCarthy said.

It seems like an eternity since the Bears have beaten McCarthy's Packers in a significant game. Minutes after Cobb scored, unfortunately timed, the song "Bad Day" blared from the Soldier Field scoreboard. The crowd of 62,708 probably thought to themselves: You have no idea. When do the NHL playoffs start? The year 2013 cannot end soon enough for our city's sports fans.

Instead of planning next weekend's tailgate party, they were left to ponder where this Bears loss ranked among Derrick Rose's injury and Chicago baseball's irrelevance among the year's disappointments. Instead of reflecting on what the playoffs meant for Trestman's first season, they were left regretting his decision to kick a field goal on second down in overtime against the Vikings and sticking with Cutler too long against the Lions.

More fodder for questioning Trestman came on a bizarre 15-yard fumble recovery returned for a touchdown by Packers wide receiver Jarrett Boykin. Peppers knocked the ball out of Rodgers' hand as he was throwing and, as everybody assumed it was an incompletion, the ball rolled downfield. Linebacker James Anderson was the most obvious defender not to pick it up, but Boykin showed the awareness every Bear lacked. Remember when the Bears defense used to run to the ball no matter what?

"There's never been a time this whole year when I've blown a whistle in practice and the ball is on the ground that we didn't pick it up and scoop and score," Trestman said. "To try and explain why that happened, I really can't at this time."

Words came easier describing Jay Cutler, who deserved better than his eighth loss to the Packers as the Bears quarterback. Cutler debunked the myth exaggerated all week that tied the Bears' winning primarily to his performance. He posted better numbers than Rodgers — 15 of 24 for 226 yards, two TDs and a passer rating of 103.8 — yet the Bears still lost because of a defensive breakdown out of his control.

Whether it's this week or next month, Cutler showed enough moxie when it mattered for the Bears to announce he will return in 2014.

"He was in total command," Trestman said.

When the emotionally draining game was over, and Sam Shields intercepted Cutler's last-ditch heave on the final play, wide receiver Brandon Marshall found keeping total command of his own feelings a challenge. As Marshall lay flat on his back on the frozen turf, his thoughts drifted to how pro athletes such as Ray Lewis and LeBron James made memorable exits after tough losses.

"I knew that wasn't a good look," Marshall said. "So I just tried to figure out the best way to move forward."

After the Bears missed the playoffs for the sixth time in seven seasons, a football city wondered the same thing.
 

Les Grossman

Well-known member
Joined:
Jun 22, 2011
Posts:
13,994
Liked Posts:
12,823
Man quote stings:

The ball landed perfectly in Cobb's hands for a touchdown that "will be running on the highlight reel for the rest of my time on this earth," Packers coach Mike McCarthy said.
 

TL1961

Well-known member
Joined:
Apr 24, 2013
Posts:
32,880
Liked Posts:
19,248
Maybe those who defend Tucker can explain how his defensive players constantly are confused by the play call.

We lost at Minnesota in a game where - on 4th and 11 - three bears weren't prepared for the snap of the ball and were looking around for signals when the play started.

Blown coverages, missed assignments, miscommunications......way too often.

How do you not hold the D coordinator responsible?
 

Flacco4Prez

New member
Joined:
Apr 19, 2013
Posts:
913
Liked Posts:
170
Man quote stings:

The ball landed perfectly in Cobb's hands for a touchdown that "will be running on the highlight reel for the rest of my time on this earth," Packers coach Mike McCarthy said.

True though. That will be on every Bears-Packers highlight compilation forever. That's a game I'll tell my kids I was at, and a play I saw
 

Chicago Staleys

Realist
Joined:
Sep 24, 2012
Posts:
12,967
Liked Posts:
8,684
It was evident Conte was playing the wrong call.

Worst is the extremely horrible blitz that left pepp that only outside C gap control
 

nihilism

Active member
Joined:
Nov 7, 2012
Posts:
159
Liked Posts:
108
I'm so pissed off at this defense!!!! Conte, Anderson, Briggs, Pepper, Paea, Wright, etc..... What the FUCK happened?? Heads really need to fucking roll!!!! They finally have a competent offense, then the defense falls apart??? Unacceptable!!! Shit, I remember when there Bears won in 1985-86 and everyone was talking about how they haven't won a championship since 1963 & thinking 'holy shit, that's soooo long ago'!! That was 22 years btwn championships.... Now here we are in 2013 - 28 years removed from a championship - soon to be 29.... This is fucking Chicago! A big market city owned and run by small minded people... ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!! 4th and 8 and there's a "miscommunication"?!?! Fuck that! I'm so sick of excuses, I want accountability..... Tucker was a HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE hire! It's obvious! Admit it & cut him loose! Sorry I'm just venting, but they HAD this fucking game!!!
 

Nail Polish

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
Aug 20, 2012
Posts:
27,609
Liked Posts:
9,559
I'm so pissed off at this defense!!!! Conte, Anderson, Briggs, Pepper, Paea, Wright, etc..... What the FUCK happened?? Heads really need to fucking roll!!!! They finally have a competent offense, then the defense falls apart??? Unacceptable!!! Shit, I remember when there Bears won in 1985-86 and everyone was talking about how they haven't won a championship since 1963 & thinking 'holy shit, that's soooo long ago'!! That was 22 years btwn championships.... Now here we are in 2013 - 28 years removed from a championship - soon to be 29.... This is fucking Chicago! A big market city owned and run by small minded people... ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!! 4th and 8 and there's a "miscommunication"?!?! Fuck that! I'm so sick of excuses, I want accountability..... Tucker was a HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE hire! It's obvious! Admit it & cut him loose! Sorry I'm just venting, but they HAD this fucking game!!!


Ive been preaching to fire Tucker in the off season all year..Seems some people want to keep him though..Why, I will never know...Next year will be horrible as well if they dont fire him no matter what players they get. The man is just not good at his profession
 

hyatt151

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
Aug 23, 2012
Posts:
11,027
Liked Posts:
3,556
I'm so pissed off at this defense!!!! Conte, Anderson, Briggs, Pepper, Paea, Wright, etc..... What the FUCK happened?? Heads really need to fucking roll!!!! They finally have a competent offense, then the defense falls apart??? Unacceptable!!! Shit, I remember when there Bears won in 1985-86 and everyone was talking about how they haven't won a championship since 1963 & thinking 'holy shit, that's soooo long ago'!! That was 22 years btwn championships.... Now here we are in 2013 - 28 years removed from a championship - soon to be 29.... This is fucking Chicago! A big market message board being over-run by small minded people... ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!! 4th and 8 and there's a "miscommunication"?!?! Fuck that! I'm so sick of excuses, I want accountability..... Tucker was a HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE hire! It's obvious! Admit it & cut him loose! Sorry I'm just venting, but they HAD this fucking game!!!


Fixed
 

ZAN

New member
Joined:
Apr 18, 2010
Posts:
1,286
Liked Posts:
356
To me it seemed that Mel Tucker called a zone blitz (evidenced by the coverage by Bowman playing deep third splitting the difference between the outside 2 WRs in the Trips and giving up the middle man to supposed centerfielder in Conte, and how Major Wright SLAMMED the inside WR on the cross in his robber coverage hook zone).

But Briggs checked late to man coverage on the blitz and called in Frey to blitz tight. Frey saw the Briggs check, Bowman and Wright and Conte didn't. So you had Frey, Briggs on one page....Bowman and Wright and Conte on the other....

Check video of the replay. You'll see Briggs signal the coverage change based on the trips coverage (too easy to flood zone in trips...right call by Briggs) when he uses his "pump" signal.

http://scores.espn.go.com/nfl/recap?gameId=331229003

go to the end and you'll see the clear zone call...they don't include Briggs pumping it up and Frey sprinting in from standing over Jordy though.
 

FirstTimer

v. 2.0: Fully Modded
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '19
Joined:
May 4, 2010
Posts:
27,077
Liked Posts:
15,163
The Bears also blew a coverage the play before this and got away with it.
 

BearDownZZ

Active member
Joined:
Aug 21, 2012
Posts:
493
Liked Posts:
419
In the end it was one bad defensive play in a string of terrible plays all year. And the broken coverage wasn't that big of a deal if you can actually blitz and get to the QB before the receiver can break open.

Anyway, we competed but we clearly don't belong amongs the playoff teams. We have a historic bad defense and it needs fixed if we want to beat Green Bay.
 

Scoot26

Administrator
Staff member
Donator
CCS Hall of Fame '20
Joined:
Jun 25, 2010
Posts:
39,863
Liked Posts:
29,979
Bears had all kinds of blown coverage on this series. There was the incomplete pass to Nelson on the left side of the field that would have given the Pack 1st and goal... and then Rodgers went right on another play and James Jones was wide fucking open for a TD. So 3rd time's a charm for the Packers.
 

bearsfootball516

Well-known member
Joined:
Jul 30, 2013
Posts:
2,096
Liked Posts:
972
In the end it was one bad defensive play in a string of terrible plays all year. And the broken coverage wasn't that big of a deal if you can actually blitz and get to the QB before the receiver can break open.

Anyway, we competed but we clearly don't belong amongs the playoff teams. We have a historic bad defense and it needs fixed if we want to beat Green Bay.

That's a key that people forget. The Bears brought 7 guys on a blitz on that play, and still somehow never got close to getting to Rodgers. How does that happen?
 

Top