dentfan
No gods! No Masters!
- Joined:
- Apr 28, 2013
- Posts:
- 4,939
- Liked Posts:
- 4,411
Steve Keim has been the Cardinals GM since 2013. At the time he fired Wilks, Keim's record as GM over 5 seasons was 49-30-1, with 2 playoff appearances.So unless your argument is the Cards had a talented enough team then it is pretty unprecedented they fired him after one year because the drunk white GM fucked up the QB pick.
I mean, part of the argument these coaches are making is that they are given shitty situations and don't get the chance to actually fail. How many black coaches have been hired for teams that aren't completely rebuilding? Tomlin? Can't think of too many more. Arizona just last week, I guess counts. Obviously, teams that are doing a complete teardown have more jobs coming open, but black coaches don't typically get jobs in situations where the coach retires or the coach has a good team but can't get over the hump. They're expected to make chicken salad out of chicken shit jobs like the Texans (now), Jets (previous years), Browns (previous years), Jags, etc.Wilks has a tough claim. He went 3-13. The last Arizona coach to do the same was fired mid-season. Arizona has had two 3 win seasons in the last 60 years.
I think that the coordinator coaches who never got a shot at head coach (but yet had similar credentials) generally have a better claim than the coaches who were eventually hired as a head coach but were not successful.
The successful cases of gender and racial discrimination usually happen because you can show a disproportionate number of people getting promoted and a disproportionate number of people getting passed over with very similar credentials. Walmart got bit pretty badly because they were able to show the number of men getting promoted versus the number of women, and it was such a large number over a long period of time that statistically it would not have happened had every candidate been on equal footing.
That was a "we don't want to throw this guy under the bus because he has nothing to do with it" statement.Kliff Kingsbury has succeeded? Uh, by what definition?
Thanks!Congrats?
Most NFL jobs fucking suck because its the same shitty franchises hiring new ones all the time. Good teams with good situations don't churn through coaches. In the same time the Patriots and Steelers have each had one coach how many have the Jets or Browns ran through? I would not be surprised if between them that number was above a dozen.I mean, part of the argument these coaches are making is that they are given shitty situations and don't get the chance to actually fail. How many black coaches have been hired for teams that aren't completely rebuilding? Tomlin? Can't think of too many more. Arizona just last week, I guess counts. Obviously, teams that are doing a complete teardown have more jobs coming open, but black coaches don't typically get jobs in situations where the coach retires or the coach has a good team but can't get over the hump. They're expected to make chicken salad out of chicken shit jobs like the Texans (now), Jets (previous years), Browns (previous years), Jags, etc.
It's going to be tough to prove either way, but it's pretty clear that there's some discrimination involved in hiring and firing practices in the NFL.
Not sure what the GMs DUI has to do with anything either. That shouldn’t be grounds for firing or not being promoted.Really don't see how staying put and drafting Rosen instead of Allen is some kind of indictment. Teams mess up picks all the time
Whenever a large requirement for hiring involves personality, fit, and the like, not just pure qualifications, the only way it can be proven is if there is a SPECIFIC incident(s) that clearly show they were fired, or not hired, due to race.From a legal perspective, that is why I think successful offensive and defensive coordinators who had multiple interviews yet never got hired have the best shot at proving discrimination. Because if they can show virtually identical resumes and a history of success at the coordinator position, it begs the question why they never got moved up. If I were Plaintiff's counsel I would love to add Bieniemy as a Plaintiff.
Bieniemys biggest issue is probably that he's been a sack of shit as a human in the past and it probably bleeds through when he interviewsFrom a legal perspective, that is why I think successful offensive and defensive coordinators who had multiple interviews yet never got hired have the best shot at proving discrimination. Because if they can show virtually identical resumes and a history of success at the coordinator position, it begs the question why they never got moved up. If I were Plaintiff's counsel I would love to add Bieniemy as a Plaintiff.
You would think it's seldom, but it's not as rare as you'd think.Most NFL jobs fucking suck because its the same shitty franchises hiring new ones all the time. Good teams with good situations don't churn through coaches. In the same time the Patriots and Steelers have each had one coach how many have the Jets or Browns ran through? I would not be surprised if between them that number was above a dozen.
Seldom is there a head coaching vacancy for a job with actual good prospects. Ironically the most recent one to open up, perhaps the head coaching vacancy set up for success I can remember, went to a black guy.
It absolutely should be grounds for firing or not being promoted. And the point is there have been plenty of players and black coaches who have had those things held against them.Not sure what the GMs DUI has to do with anything either. That shouldn’t be grounds for firing or not being promoted.
Dude…Dante stallworth literally was drunk and killed someone in a drunk driving incident and was back in the league the following year. One DUI shouldn’t be grounds for firing and has nothing to do with the alleged racism claims. The point is bunk as all funkIt absolutely should be grounds for firing or not being promoted. And the point is there have been plenty of players and black coaches who have had those things held against them.
It literally does have to do with the racism claims because the claim is that he was treated unfairly by being fired for going 3-13, while the GM who hired him and put together said 3-13 team, had a DUI and got to hire his 3rd coach, which is nearly unprecedented. Black coach fired. White drunk GM, extended. All by white owner. THAT'S THE RACISM HE'S CLAIMING!Dude…Dante stallworth literally was drunk and killed someone in a drunk driving incident and was back in the league the following year. One DUI shouldn’t be grounds for firing and has nothing to do with the alleged racism claims. The point is bunk as all funk