Pre 2016 QB Rankings.

[hyatt151]

1. Cam Newton CAR
2. Aaron Rodgers GB
3. Russell Wilson SEA
4. Andrew Luck IND
5. Drew Brees NO
6. Ben Roethlisberger PIT
7. Carson Palmer ARI
8. Tom Brady NE
9. Eli Manning NYG
10. Blake Bortles JAC
11. Philip Rivers SD
12. Tyrod Taylor BUF
13. Tony Romo DAL
14. Kirk Cousins WAS
15. Derek Carr OAK
16. Marcus Mariota TEN
17. Matthew Stafford DET
18. Andy Dalton CIN
19. Jameis Winston TB
20. Ryan Tannehill MIA
21. Matt Ryan ATL
22. Brock Osweiler HOU
23. Joe Flacco BAL
24. Ryan Fitzpatrick FA
25. Jay Cutler CHI
26. Teddy Bridgewater MIN
27. Alex Smith KC
28. Jared Goff LA
29. Colin Kaepernick SF
30. Sam Bradford PHI
31. Robert Griffin III CLE
32. Paxton Lynch DEN
33. Geno Smith NYJ
34. Jimmy Garoppolo NE
35. Mark Sanchez DEN
36. Carson Wentz PHI
37. Case Keenum LA
38. Blaine Gabbert SF
39. Josh McCown CLE
40. Brian Hoyer CHI

Discuss!!

 

[Novak]

Only 15 spots between our franchise QB and our backup. That depth mane.

Baers superbowl in 2016?

 

[Newblood]

The list is shit. That's all.

 

[hckypro19ja]

I hate the guy just as much as the next, but any list that doesn't have Tom Brady in the top 3, is a joke until he starts his "decline". And putting Wilson, Palmer and hell even Newton ahead of him is just laughable.

 

[legendxofxlink]

1. Cam Newton CAR
2. Aaron Rodgers GB
3. Russell Wilson SEA
4. Andrew Luck IND
5. Drew Brees NO
6. Ben Roethlisberger PIT
7. Carson Palmer ARI
8. Tom Brady NE
9. Eli Manning NYG
10. Blake Bortles JAC
11. Philip Rivers SD
12. Tyrod Taylor BUF
13. Tony Romo DAL
14. Kirk Cousins WAS
15. Derek Carr OAK
16. Marcus Mariota TEN
17. Matthew Stafford DET
18. Andy Dalton CIN
19. Jameis Winston TB
20. Ryan Tannehill MIA
21. Matt Ryan ATL
22. Brock Osweiler HOU
23. Joe Flacco BAL
24. Ryan Fitzpatrick FA
25. Jay Cutler CHI
26. Teddy Bridgewater MIN
27. Alex Smith KC
28. Jared Goff LA
29. Colin Kaepernick SF
30. Sam Bradford PHI
31. Robert Griffin III CLE
32. Paxton Lynch DEN
33. Geno Smith NYJ
34. Jimmy Garoppolo NE
35. Mark Sanchez DEN
36. Carson Wentz PHI
37. Case Keenum LA
38. Blaine Gabbert SF
39. Josh McCown CLE
40. Brian Hoyer CHI

Discuss!!

Theres a guy not even on a team going to have a better year than Bears QB, lol.

 

[DC]

Sandwiched between Fitzpatrick and Bridgwater. Sounds about right, lol

 

[freddylamar]

Tyrod Taylor @ 12?

 

[iueyedoc]

Too High
Too Low
1. Cam Newton CAR
2. Aaron Rodgers GB
3. Russell Wilson SEA
4. Andrew Luck INDOR]
5. Drew Brees NO
6. Ben Roethlisberger PIT
7. Carson Palmer ARI
8. Tom Brady NE
9. Eli Manning NYG
10. Blake Bortles JAC
11. Philip Rivers SD
12. Tyrod Taylor BUF
13. Tony Romo DAL
14. Kirk Cousins WAS
15. Derek Carr OAK
16. Marcus Mariota TEN
17. Matthew Stafford DET
18. Andy Dalton CIN
19. Jameis Winston TB
20. Ryan Tannehill MIA
21. Matt Ryan ATL
22. Brock Osweiler HOU
23. Joe Flacco BAL
24. Ryan Fitzpatrick FA
25. Jay Cutler CHI
26. Teddy Bridgewater MIN
27. Alex Smith KC
28. Jared Goff LA
29. Colin Kaepernick SF
30. Sam Bradford PHI
31. Robert Griffin III CLE
32. Paxton Lynch DEN
33. Geno Smith NYJ
34. Jimmy Garoppolo NE
35. Mark Sanchez DEN
36. Carson Wentz PHI
37. Case Keenum LA
38. Blaine Gabbert SF
39. Josh McCown CLE
40. Brian Hoyer CHI

 

[didshereallysaythat]

I still don't know why everyone overrates Luck at this point.

 

[SilenceS]

I still don't know why everyone overrates Luck at this point.

Yea, I know a 26 year old QB who will probably be a great QB for the next decade is over rated. I see it now. That 40TD's and 16 INT's the year before was just terrible. He also has some of the greatest offensive weapons in the league. Wait, what?

 

[Bigdaddybear]

Way too high for mariota and Winston.

 

[WCL]

It comes down to ruining a perfectly good pair of pantyhose or getting piss on your balls.

 

[Hawkeye OG]

This would be my top 10.

1. Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Cam
4. Luck
5. Russel
6. Big Ben
7. Brees
8. Palmer
9. Rivers
10. Manning (only because the 2 SB’s

Bortles is NOT a top 10 QB.

 

[bearmick]

Switch Brady and Luck and it's about right.

 

[baselman1974]

TyrodnTaylor at 12 when Buffalo was looking to draft his replacement. WTF? Also Fitzgerald is not even signed yet.

 

[da_bears6]

I love the recency bias in the NFL. I wonder where the OP had Nick Foles after his 27 TD 2 INT season heading into 2014.

Newton/Wilson in the top 5 is just wrong.

 

[Warrior Spirit]

Too High
Too Low
1. Cam Newton CAR
2. Aaron Rodgers GB
3. Russell Wilson SEA
4. Andrew Luck IND
5. Drew Brees NO
6. Ben Roethlisberger PIT
7. Carson Palmer ARI
8. Tom Brady NE
9. Eli Manning NYG
10. Blake Bortles JAC
11. Philip Rivers SD
12. Tyrod Taylor BUF
13. Tony Romo DAL
14. Kirk Cousins WAS
15. Derek Carr OAK
16. Marcus Mariota TEN
17. Matthew Stafford DET
18. Andy Dalton CIN
19. Jameis Winston TB
20. Ryan Tannehill MIA
21. Matt Ryan ATL
22. Brock Osweiler HOU
23. Joe Flacco BAL
24. Ryan Fitzpatrick FA
25. Jay Cutler CHI
26. Teddy Bridgewater MIN
27. Alex Smith KC
28. Jared Goff LA
29. Colin Kaepernick SF
30. Sam Bradford PHI
31. Robert Griffin III CLE
32. Paxton Lynch DEN
33. Geno Smith NYJ
34. Jimmy Garoppolo NE
35. Mark Sanchez DEN
36. Carson Wentz PHI
37. Case Keenum LA
38. Blaine Gabbert SF
39. Josh McCown CLE
40. Brian Hoyer CHI

 

[pseudonym]

This would be my top 10.

1. Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Cam
4. Luck
5. Russel
6. Big Ben
7. Brees
8. Palmer
9. Rivers
10. Manning (only because the 2 SB’s

Bortles is NOT a top 10 QB.

Dude was like #5 last year. Your statement is invalid.

 

[bearmick]

TyrodnTaylor at 12 when Buffalo was looking to draft his replacement. WTF? Also Fitzgerald is not even signed yet.

LOL you think they drafted Cardale Jones to replace him? They drafted a 4th round prospect primarily for depth since they have nothing else, and because Taylor has only played one full season and that's not enough to ignore the position. I wish the Bears paid as much attention to the most important position in the game.

Taylor was solid last year. Six picks and a +14 TD-int diff, and 8 yards per attempt and a ball hair off a triple digit passer rating. Not big numbers but efficient numbers.

 

[PrideisBears]

This really is a terrible list. Joe was awful last year and with trestman the results will get worse, Winston, Tannehill and oOz need to below Cutler. The sheep mentality on this board needs it's own study.


He'll Fitz needs to below Cutler too. I know he had one good year after nothing but bad to mediocre but even the Jets realize it probably won't happen again