Top 25 Chicago Blackhawks

[hawksfanmd]

I saw this and wondered what the Nation thought of this,do you agree with the list or what changes would you make to it?

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/4484 ... blackhawks

 

[E Runs]

Where's the list?

 

[hawksfanmd]

[quote name="E Runs"]Where's the list?[/quote]

Sorry about that I added the link to the first post

 

[Guest]

Vince Vaughn doesn't deserve any mention except for being a Bandwagon fan who went to games when they were good.



Not a bad list. Wish Kaner would fit on there somewhere but I think he'll be in the top 10 if he stays with the Hawks past this contract.

 

[Chief Walking Stick]

For you lazyasses:

The following players did NOT make the cut for the Top 25 Blackhawks of All Time:



Patrick Sharp

Patrick Kane

Eric Daze

Steve Sullivan

Alexei Zhamnov

Darryl Sutter

Grant Mulvey

Bill Mosienko

Here's the beginning of the list:



#25 - Jonathan Toews



http://bleacherreport.com/articles/4484 ... wks#page/3

 

[PatrickSharpRules]

Toews should be higher, even in his 3 years he's accomplished enough to be in the teens.

 

[Ton]

Not sure Zhamnov even deserves to be an honorable mention, although he was a serviceable player, he certainly wasn't anything special. Might as well put Havlat there while they are at it.



IMO Kaner deserves to be on the list.



Also how is Jonathan #2 on the captain list (ahead of guys like Cheli, Amonte, etc.. etc..) yet he is #25 on the overall list?



Not even an honorable mention for Seabrook? Yeah OK!

 

[E Runs]

[quote name="Ton"]Not sure Zhamnov even deserves to be an honorable mention, although he was a serviceable player, he certainly wasn't anything special. Might as well put Havlat there while they are at it.



IMO Kaner deserves to be on the list.



Also how is Jonathan #2 on the captain list (ahead of guys like Cheli, Amonte, etc.. etc..) yet he is #25 on the overall list?



Not even an honorable mention for Seabrook? Yeah OK![/quote]

Keep in mind this is the same place (Bleecher Report) that floated the theory that Hawks should get Khabi back.

 

[BiscuitintheBasket]

[quote name="Ton"]Not sure Zhamnov even deserves to be an honorable mention, although he was a serviceable player, he certainly wasn't anything special. Might as well put Havlat there while they are at it.



IMO Kaner deserves to be on the list.



Also how is Jonathan #2 on the captain list (ahead of guys like Cheli, Amonte, etc.. etc..) yet he is #25 on the overall list?



Not even an honorable mention for Seabrook? Yeah OK![/quote]





Not that I think Archie was an awesome player, but take a look at how his stats as a 'Hawk compares to other 'Hawks. He is ranked rather nicely from a 'Hawks stats perspective...and he did not always have the benefit of a strong cast (along with Amonte).



I agree on Kane. He should be on the list, but I struggle with whom to pull off.

 

[Guest]

[quote name="E Runs"]

Keep in mind this is the same place (Bleecher Report) that floated the theory that Hawks should get Khabi back.[/quote]





I think the bleacher report lands somewhere right above Rozner on my list of knowing what the fuck they are talking about most of the time. I think Eklund beats them both and that speaks volumes.

 

[CLWolf81]

[quote name="Ton"]Not sure Zhamnov even deserves to be an honorable mention, although he was a serviceable player, he certainly wasn't anything special. Might as well put Havlat there while they are at it.[/quote]



If they want to go that route, they could have put in Ed Belfour in there.... He was a great Hawk goalie before he ended up drinking the rest of his career away with other teams.

 

[Variable]

Why is this list even being discussed? Anyone can write for the Bleacher Report. Literally anyone. Just register for free, and BOOM, you can be Rozner without the pay check within minutes.