I think is more a personal philosophy difference. Neither is wrong. My not wanting to pay A-Rob definitely skewes my opinion. We just have so many holes and need that cap money.
Williams would absolutely be less productive in every category. But he could still play a big role in the red zone as a big possession reviever and while giving more opportunity to Mooney/Kmet and any other youth positions players we draft to develop. In this offense(ESPECIALLY with Cohen coming back), how will anyone else develop with Robinson catching 100 balls a year.
Just Can’t keep A-Rob. Good player but he’s too expensive, we have way too many holes, and we could get great value for him in tag/trade.