Ultimate All-Star Teams (MLB)

[X]

Over the course of the next few weeks, I'm going to conduct a series of polls to determine who the absolute best of the best is from each League, and then we'll have a vote to see who we all think would win between the best of the AL and the best of the NL in a 5 game series (due to having 5 SPs). This list will be viewed as these teams will play THIS YEAR...so we don't have to worry about projecting players for future seasons or basing solely off past accomplishments.

We are going to start with Starting Pitchers in the AL and NL. Please Vote accordingly...top 5 advance. Due to the ridiculous number of quality starters, this will not be a typical poll. You will type out your top 5, and I'll compile the #s after a couple days. Please select exactly 5 from each league.

The following list is just to jog your memory. It is NOT a limited list.

NL:
Roy Halladay - Phi
Cliff Lee - Phi
Cole Hamels - Phi
Tim Hudson - Atl
Tommy Hanson - Atl
Jair Jurrgens - Atl
Carlos Zambrano - Chi
Yovani Gallardo - Mil
Zack Grienke - Mil
Josh Johnson - Fla
Clayton Kershaw - LA
Tim Lincecum - SF
Matt Cain - SF
Other - Write In

AL:
Jared Weaver - LA
Dan Haren - LA
Trevor Cahill - Oak
James Shields - TB
David Price - TB
Jon Lester - Bos
Josh Beckett - Bos
CC Sabathia - NY
Phil Humber -Chi
Justin Verlander - Det
Felix Hernandez - Sea
Fausto Carmono - Cle
Francisco Liriano - Min
Other - Write In

 

[X]

Mine:

NL:
Halladay (1)
C. Lee (1)
Lincecum (1)
J. Johnson (1)
Gallardo (1)

AL:
Weaver (1)
Price (1)
Sabathia (1)
Hernandez (1)
Haren (1)

 

[HighJump31]

NL
1. Roy Halladay
2. Josh Johnson
3. Cliff Lee
4. Tim Lincecum
5. Jaime Garcia

AL
1. Felix Hernandez
2. David Price
3. Jon Lester
4. CC Sabathia
5. Trevor Cahill

 

[Gunzaan]

I don't really understand what you are doing, it is too hard to give a subjective vote for other "quality" pitchers because there might be some people who aren't watching other teams. Roy Halladay is above and beyond the best pitcher in the game. It isn't even close.

I don't even want to vote for anyone else because it will give them votes, so I guess if you want to tally votes for a poll, I will go

NL
1. Roy Halladay
2. Who knows? I guess Josh Johnson
3. Who knows? I guess Lincecum
4. Who knows? I guess Cliff Lee
5. Who knows? I guess Clayton Kershaw

AL
1. Who knows? King Felix
2. Who knows? Jared Weaver
3. Who knows? I guess Lester
4. Who knows? I guess Sabathia
5. Who knows? I guess Verlander

None of it matters, Halladay is the best pitcher in MLB, far and above anyone else in either league. It isn't even close, we are watching something special. The amount of pitches in his arsenal and the way he knows how to pitch every single fucking hitter is unmatched in this era. I really shouldn't of even voted for any of the other pitchers because they aren't in his class but I don't want to look like a Special person.

 

[X]

I don't really understand what you are doing, it is too hard to give a subjective vote for other "quality" pitchers because there might be some people who aren't watching other teams. Roy Halladay is above and beyond the best pitcher in the game. It isn't even close.

I don't even want to vote for anyone else because it will give them votes, so I guess if you want to tally votes for a poll, I will go

NL
1. Roy Halladay
2. Who knows? I guess Josh Johnson
3. Who knows? I guess Lincecum
4. Who knows? I guess Cliff Lee
5. Who knows? I guess Clayton Kershaw

AL
1. Who knows? King Felix
2. Who knows? Jared Weaver
3. Who knows? I guess Lester
4. Who knows? I guess Sabathia
5. Who knows? I guess Verlander

None of it matters, Halladay is the best pitcher in MLB, far and above anyone else in either league. It isn't even close, we are watching something special. The amount of pitches in his arsenal and the way he knows how to pitch every single fucking hitter is unmatched in this era. I really shouldn't of even voted for any of the other pitchers because they aren't in his class but I don't want to look like a Special person.

Relax Bro. Just a fun little thing on a msg board. No one willl "look like a Special person" unless they make fun of some one else's opinions.

geez, lay off the coffee

 

[AE23]

My List, in order of course

NL
Roy Halladay
Cliff Lee
Tim Lincecum
Josh Johnson
Adam Wainwright

AL
C.C. Sabathia
Felix Hernandez
Jered Weaver
Justin Verlander
David Price

 

[X]

My List, in order of course

NL
Roy Halladay
Felix Hernandez
Tim Lincecum
Cliff Lee
Adam Wainwright

AL
C.C. Sabathia
Jered Weaver
Justin Verlander
David Price
Dan Haren

Excellent picks bro...but King Felix is in the AL...

 

[AE23]

derp, will edit now, i was think i was missin someone in the AL,..... gimme a break, i woke up, not hung over, still drunk, lol

 

[AE23]

Mine:

NL:
Halladay (1)
C. Lee (1)
Lincecum (1)
J. Johnson (1)
Gallardo (1)

AL:
Weaver (1)
Price (1)
Sabathia (1)
Hernandez (1)
Haren (1)

Yovani Gallardo, idk, def their ace, btw, Ive met the guy, and had a couple of convertions with em, i dont have the pic anymore, but I talked to em, and i told em I was a Cubs fan(this was back in 07-08and I was feelin cocky cuz we were good), and yeah we had a couple of chuckles. and in the pic, I was wearing a WhiteSox cap, lol

 

[USCChiFan]

NL:
1. Roy Halladay
2. Josh Johnson
3. Cliff Lee
4. Tim Lincecum
5. Clayton Kershaw

AL:
1. CC Sabathia
2. Felix Hernandez
3. Jared Weaver
4. David Price
5. Justin Verlander

 

[CODE_BLUE56]

NL:
Roy Halladay
Josh Johnson
Cliff Lee
Lincecum
Kershaw

AL(alot more talent in pitching..)
1.Felix
2.CC
3.Price
4.Weaver
5.Verlander

honorable mention:Cahill and Haren

 

[Jntg4]

NL:
Halladay
Lee
Lincecum
Johnson
Kershaw

AL:
Sabathia
Hernandez
Price
Verlander
CARLOS SILVA

 

[HighJump31]

Excellent picks bro...but King Felix is in the AL...

And Wainwright is done for this year and half of next. Or else I would have voted for him

 

[X]

<3 you guys. Keep voting...we'll knock this whole thing out in a cpl weeks.

 

[poodski]

Halladay
Lee
Johnson
Lincecum
Carpenter

Sabathia
Felix
Cahill
Weaver
Lester

 

[bobferg]

NL
Doc
Cliff Lee
Timmy Jim Jam
Clayton Kershaw
Jair Jurrjens.

AL
King
Verlander
Little Weaver
CC
David Price

 

[Uman85]

NL
Roy Halladay
Cliff Lee
Tim Lincecum
Ubaldo Jimenez
Clayton Kershaw



AL
Felix Hernandez
Jered Weaver
Dan Haren
Justin Verlander
David Price

 

[X]

Keep it coming guys...We'll leave this open until tomorrow night or the next night, then do the next poll.

 

[HighJump31]

X, are we allowed to vote for guys that won't pitch this year like Wainwright? If so, I'm changing my Jaime Garcia vote to Wainwright.

 

[X]

X, are we allowed to vote for guys that won't pitch this year like Wainwright? If so, I'm changing my Jaime Garcia vote to Wainwright.

This list will be viewed as these teams will play THIS YEAR...so we don't have to worry about projecting players for future seasons or basing solely off past accomplishments.

.