Who's the best Rock Band of all time and why is it Led Zeppelin?

[Leomaz]

well might as well lock this thread. its ruined by ommy as usual

 

[Omeletpants]

Here is Jimmy Page as a studio musician for Joe Cocker doing a cheesy solo at 1:40. Critics panned his performance. Mick Taylor would have blown off the roof

 

[ijustposthere]

well might as well lock this thread. its ruined by ommy as usual

Basically. His posts are as subpar as his guitar hero. You can see how Rolling Stone mag has them ranked here:

100 Greatest Guitarists: David Fricke's Picks

David Fricke picks the best and most influential guitarists in rock – from Jerry Garcia and Joan Jett to B.B. King and Jimi Hendrix.

www.rollingstone.com

If you're looking for Ommy's hero, he's a little farther down the list.

 

[ytsejam]

Metallica was simply better than Megadeth. Period.

That by no means that one doesn't cheat on their favorite band by enjoying other bands. It just means that on the pedestal it is simply Metallica, Pantera, and everyone else when it concerns heavy metal.

I don't know man. The sun must have cooked your brane or something.
Metallica up to Justice was badass. I'll give them all the props in the world for that but let's look at releases.

1988 - And Justice For All
1988 - So Far So Good So What
Both great albums but So far is the more technical album.

1990 - Rust in Peace
1991 - Black Album
Enough fucking said.

1992 - Countdown to Extinction
Only half as good as Rust but still twice as good as Black album.

I loved Pantera when I was younger, saw them 6 times but Slayer and Anthrax are both far better bands.

 

[Omeletpants]

Basically. His posts are as subpar as his guitar hero. You can see how Rolling Stone mag has them ranked here:

100 Greatest Guitarists: David Fricke's Picks

David Fricke picks the best and most influential guitarists in rock – from Jerry Garcia and Joan Jett to B.B. King and Jimi Hendrix.

www.rollingstone.com

If you're looking for Ommy's hero, he's a little farther down the list.

Rankings change all the time. THey had Bonnie Raitt around 60 and excluded the legend Brian Setzer >>YAWN>>>

 

[Omeletpants]

Taylor jamming at a small venue

 

[ijustposthere]

Rankings change all the time. THey had Bonnie Raitt around 60 and excluded the legend Brian Setzer >>YAWN>>>

And yet, your boy Mick Taylor probably doesn't ever touch the great Jimmy Page. LOLOLOLOLOLO PAGEY!

 

[Leomaz]

Rankings change all the time. THey had Bonnie Raitt around 60 and excluded the legend Brian Setzer >>YAWN>>>

Your ranking has always been at the bottom.

 

[Omeletpants]

Your ranking has always been at the bottom.

What did you think of the shit solo Page did on the cocker song?

 

[JPPT1974]

Love Queen. Freddie Mercury RIP!

 

[Leomaz]

And yet, your boy Mick Taylor probably doesn't ever touch the great Jimmy Page. LOLOLOLOLOLO PAGEY!

Mick Taylor was a decent guitar player but he doesn’t sniff the top 50. If even that.

 

[Omeletpants]

Keith Richards who most consider the greatest rhythm guitarist claim Taylor is a virtuoso. Charlie Watts and Bill Wyman have stated the Stones only became a great live band once Taylor joined.

 

[ijustposthere]

Keith Richards who most consider the greatest rhythm guitarist claim Taylor is a virtuoso. Charlie Watts and Bill Wyman have stated the Stones only became a great live band once Taylor joined.

That's so awesome. You know who else was a great live band? Led Zeppelin.

 

[Omeletpants]

That's so awesome. You know who else was a great live band? Led Zeppelin.

Actually they arent. The are legendary for druken and sloppy perfromances

 

[Leomaz]

Actually they arent. The are legendary for druken and sloppy perfromances

According to you, dumb ass, the stones have been stealing peoples money since 1974......46 friggin years you bloody twit.

 

[JimAKABlkhwks918]

I like the Stones as well. The Taylor years are some of my favorites. That said, putting Taylor ahead of Page is just ridiculous. Taylor wouldn't put himself ahead of Page, you fucking halfwit.

I also love Richards, but Malcolm Young is the Rickey Henderson of rhythm guitarists...second isn't even close.

As for the Stones version of Stop Breaking Down, it's meh at best; one of the weak points of the brilliant Exile On Main Street double album. This is a much better version: a visceral, stripped down, distorted romp..

 

[Omeletpants]

One of the best songs about anal sex ever

 

[Omeletpants]

I like the Stones as well. The Taylor years are some of my favorites. That said, putting Taylor ahead of Page is just ridiculous. Taylor wouldn't put himself ahead of Page, you fucking halfwit.

I also love Richards, but Malcolm Young is the Rickey Henderson of rhythm guitarists...second isn't even close.

As for the Stones version of Stop Breaking Down, it's meh at best; one of the weak points of the brilliant Exile On Main Street double album. This is a much better version: a visceral, stripped down, distorted romp..

Yeah, Taylor would put himself ahead of Page and Zep

The Stones never respected Zep and they thought they were a heavy handed band that stole other people's songs without giving them credit

Malcolm is one dimensional as all their songs sound the same. AC/DC couldnt play blues for shit. Richard is the riff king and greatest rythym guitarist. No one created more memorable riffs than Richards. The average fan cant name 2 AC/DC songs

Taylor is better than all of them. Was the best slide player in 1971, best lead guitarist and a legendary blues man

 

[Leomaz]

Breaking news.....just released new single by the new band called The Shags. It has @The Hawk on guitar, @noprophet on guitar and @Omeletpants on drums.....listen at your own discretion

 

[Leomaz]

Yeah, Taylor would put himself ahead of Page and Zep

The Stones never respected Zep and they thought they were a heavy handed band that stole other people's songs without giving them credit

Malcolm is one dimensional as all their songs sound the same. AC/DC couldnt play blues for shit. Richard is the riff king and greatest rythym guitarist. No one created more memorable riffs than Richards. The average fan cant name 2 AC/DC songs

Taylor is better than all of them. Was the best slide player in 1971, best lead guitarist and a legendary blues man

ummmm. No. That is all