Hughes
Kappo
Turcottte
Byram
Cozens
Stan will go with the local kid, and once again pull his Jerry Angelo "smartest guy in the room" bullshit.
Thing is Turcotte would be a good pick in my opinion. Aside from Hughes, he's the best center of the draft class and has more hockeyIQ and a higher floor* than Cozens or the others. I'm like 55-45 on Byram but I don't think the 'hawks lose with Turcotte.
However, I do think there's a chance, and a significant one at that, that Stan pretends like he's the smartest guy in the room, and gets Caulfield.
* - I think that the major problem a lot of people are doing with this draft is they're looking at the highest ceiling, and not the highest floor. With pick 3 we have an excellent chance at getting a piece that will be *the* next guy in terms of deployment: Either the next Keith (Byram), next Toews (Turcotte or Hughes if he drops), or an outsdie chance of the next Hossa (Kakko if he drops). In that respect, safer is better than a gamble.
Realistically I think Byram bottoms out as a mid-pair defenseman if all goes wrong. Realistically it's about the same for Turcotte: a middle C. Aside from Hughes and Kakko: in my opinion guys like Cozens, Dach, etc. have the lowest floors--some of them being a Barker or worse, a Beach. I think it's a major consideration because barring a complete pants-downer of a year coming up this might be the best shot the 'hawks have at getting the next generation of talent.
And while I don't think a guy like Caufield has a low floor, I don't think he's the BPA at 3 given his O-only game, and further if anything he's the next Kane or Debrincat--the two players on the team which will probably be the most viable the longest. So in my opinion he's not the guy to get--but again, Stan pretending he's the smartest guy in the room makes me worried he'd try that.