- Joined:
- Nov 27, 2014
- Posts:
- 18,850
- Liked Posts:
- 4,656
No one ever does an All-whatever team based on projections. The dude is trolling, that's why his list is shit. You, however, have lost your mind if you think Cook should be on the list over Howard. The only two positions in the OPs original crap list that aren't up for debate are QB and RB. That's not me denouncing Cook's talent or prospective future, it's based on what they've done so far
It's debatable whether Thielen is even the best WR on his own team. Robinson being on the list is debatable. It certainly isn't a "no way."
.
If it is based on what they have done so far, as you say, then Robinson being on the list is a no go. One sub par year, one Outstanding year, one good year and one injured year averages out to nothing more than above average.
At least when I project Cook, who like Robinson, is coming off injury, it is from last years performance, not something 3 years ago......not to mention you seem to be operating under the assumption the only reason I say Roberson doesn't belong on that list is due to his injury, which it is not, rather I think his 2016 production is much closer to what to expect from him if he returns to form.