Westbrook and Rose have very similar styles, though Rose is a bit better. I am on twitter right now arguing with a guy who played pro ball, thinks Westbrook would be better than Rose if he was in Chicago. I disagree, but its not like it doesn't make sense. As I stated, styles very similar.
Well its impossible to make an argument about how good a guy would be on a different team because fact is, theres absolutely no way of proving it. Maybe Rose could rack up 12 assists a game alongside arguably the best scorer in the NBA. Its hard to compare players when one guy is the first scoring option and passer to a guy whos the second scoring option and first passer.
Dan can compare rebounding #s but the surrounding players play a factor in it. Westbrook averages half an assist more but plays next to Durant and Rose missed his 2nd scoring option for a big part of the season, Noah as well. He says Westbrook is a better thief, but Rose has better block #s. He knocks Rose's shooting % yet Westbrook only shoots .006 better. Is that that significant? He fails to mention FT%, which Rose has been spectacular as of late. Westbrook also turns the ball over .5 more a game.
You could twist your arguments and skew the stats(which most sports based internet arguments are) but fact is you have to just watch these guys and see what theyve meant to their team. I watch a lot of Thunder games. Theyre one of the 6 or 7 teams i selected to watch on my league pass broadband. Westbrook is the 2nd most important player to his team and fact is, the Thunder would really struggle without him. But hes not their best player. Rose's squad is arguably more talented as a whole if you look at the whole, finished product. But if Rose went down theres no one that could put the Bulls on his back and win. The Thunder would always have the face of the franchise and best player...Kevin Durant.
Le Baturd was on the Waddle and Silvy show a moment ago and i just listened to him and Silvy debate this whole Rose-Westbrook thing. Both of these guys are just glorified fans. Neither made a good point.