Hey, we agree on something. Passing stats are not more valuable than points. Progress! Now I will do you the same courtesy and answer your questions.
1. Is Claypool better than Ja'Marr Chase? No. Never have claimed he would be.
2. Will Claypool ever boost Fields passing production to the levels we are seeing from Burrow? No. They're two polar opposite style of quarterbacks. I previously stated in this very thread that I thought Claypool was a #3 receiver and that the 2nd round pick was a drastic overpay.
3. Do I think the Bears will be competing for a Super Bowl next year? No. I've been consistent on saying I want a top 5 pick in 2022. A top 5 to 10 pick in 2023. A top 15-20 pick in 2024 and a legitimate playoff contender in 2025.
This team has holes all over the place. One receiver is not going to make the difference in this team being immediate Super Bowl contenders when the Bears could be replacing as many as 9 starters on defense in addition to a minimum of 3 new offensive linemen, a true #1 receiver, a true #2 receiver and likely replacing a starting RB as I doubt Montgomery gets a new deal (despite my appreciation of him).
4. Where will the Bears be in 2023 if they go with Claypool and Johnson? Hopefully picking in the top 10 as previously stated.
5. Will Fields boost Claypool and Johnston into a playoff team? I absolutely believe Fields can lead this team to the playoffs. Whether Claypool or Johnston is on the team is irrelevant in that belief.
6. What if the Bears go defense 1st and take WR in 2nd round, will they be a playoff team next year? No. Again, see entire answer 3.
7. I have never claimed Justin Fields would become a top 5 passer. Do I think it's a possibility? Sure, it can happen. Do I think it's likely though? No. He's a dual threat QB. With a better supporting cast, it should open up the passing game more.
As an example - if the Bears go 4 WR, 1 RB set - the defense has to choose between sticking with 2 high safeties but not being able to double team anybody or they'd have to stick to a single high safety look while doubling the #1 receiver. If they want to stick to 2 high safeties while still doubling the #1 receiver, they sacrifice an additional lineman up front which gives Fields and better receivers more time to win their individual matchups. Fields running ability requires a spy on every single play which forces defenses into picking their poison. Rush fewer players but risk longer pocket times or 1 single high safety against a QB who routinely makes great deep passes. If you decide not to spy on a given play and the Bears are passing, he runs for a first down or more.