I don't buy this for a second, they would have us believe that a 4 year starter, upperclassman and "one of the best qbs in college football" wasn't voted team captain because they had a strong core of seniors? No. I don't believe it.
Edit: Not that you can't be a good football player and not be a leader, but do you really want to go through that again?
Well, why do you think he wasn't the team captain? Are you suggestion that the team is lying? Why hasn't at least 1 player said something remotely negative? Why don't you look up who the team captains were and debunk the myth. I know it is easy to ride the same media rumor train that got half the people to believe Aaron Donald was 3/4" to short to PLAY in the NFL.
Think about what you are saying for a minute... its kinda silly actually.
If he blew of meetings and wasn't there for his team -- That's a red flag
If he always kept to himself and seemed uncomfortable with his teammates -- That's a red flag
If he acted like he was better then his teammates and snubbed them (Jimmy Clausen)-- That's a red flag
If he found out he wasn't team captain and took a fit -- That's a red flag
If he accepted the fact that their are other GREAT leaders on the team, but continued to practice hard, show faith in teammates, and lead his team in the huddle on game day despite not winning the popularity contest... then that show he is a good leader.