I'm not a football history stat nerd like some of you, so I genuinely don't know this (and don't care enough to research it), but are most backs with that kind of production in the HOF or not? Now that he's no longer a Bear I don't particularly care so much, but it seems to me he's on a similar track as plenty of guys who are or could/should eventually be - Curtis Martin, Marcus Allen, Tomlinson type career production.
Edit: ok I did look a little. not sure who is and isn't in the hall, but of the three people I mentioned -
Martin - 17,430 in 11 seasons (1,584 per)
Allen - 17,654 in 16 seasons (1,103 per)
Tomlinson - 18,456 in 11 season (1,678 per)
Forte - 12,718 in 8 seasons (1,590 per)
So 3 more seasons at avg production puts him well into that group (yes we've heard countless times before how all of these players with similar numbers to Forte are all supposedly better than him, but the numbers are the numbers).
Forte hasn't been as productive as those guys though. Yards are yards, yes, but Allen has huge TD totals(144). So does Tomlinson(162), and so does Martin(100).
Martin's five biggest TD years(67 total)surpass Forte's entire career total(64). You trying to paint Forte as being as productive as those guys just isn't true.
Forte has yet to lead the league in any major rushing category. All those guys did. Hell, Martin lead the NFL in rushing at age 31.
Even the "weak link" of the Martin, LT, Allen combo (Martin) made five Pro Bowls and an All Pro team. He was also ROY.
Allen won ROY, Super Bowl MVP, and NFL MVP and made six Pro Bowls and two All Pro teams.
LT: Five Pro Bowls(shocked this number isn't higher actually) 3x AP along with an MVP award.
Forte has only made two pro bowls and zero all pro teams.
Forte has been a darn fine NFL RB for his career but there's just no "pop" on his resume. He's a compiler so far without the payoff.
I find it funny that now that he's not on the Bears you don't care as much because I said the same thing two years ago on this subject. Had Forte had his career production with most any other NFL team no one here would even really be thinking about him for the HOF.
To expand further, if I was offered a guy like Shaun Alexander(won't make the HOF) and was told I could have his five year stretch (01-05) or Forte's Bears career..I'd take Alexander pretty easily.
I guess Forte to me is kind of Tiki Barber-ish(production wise) but even if Tiki ever made the hall(
highly doubtful) He's made more PB's, more AP teams and lead the league in total yards from scrimmage twice.
I just can't envision Forte making the HOF via the normal ballot.