I wouldn't call making the playoffs 4 out of 5 yrs nothing. I wouldn't call sweeping the defending champion heat and taking the defending champion celtics to 7 nothing. BG has done a lot. Deng may have been the most complete player on the bulls that year but BG was clearly the most valuable. He carried us down the stretch and was the focal point of the offense. Watch BG's career, he will be remembered in the same thoughts as Miller and Allen. His career averages through this point compare very well.
Seriously Elton Brand? He is underrated in the zach randolph department. For all his talent he has only been to the playoffs ONCE!!!! And now he is falling apart. He has so little impact on any of the team he played on. How many other 20 and 10 big man have only made the playoffs once?
Quit acting like the Heat were at the top of their game, Wade was 50% healthy in the playoffs that year and really shouldn't have come back. As far as the Celtics, if they had Garnett is that a 7 game series? BG has done a lot? What about the other players? He wasn't hands down better than anyone else to make it seems as if "he led the team" anywhere. Deng was the best, most valuable or whatever you want to call it in the '07 season, point blank.
You are right, he is underrated, comparing him to Randolph is just nonsensical. When he was here, he was a better player than Gordon, no matter how you throw up the stats, he was a better player. I would take Elton Brand at that time over Ben Gordon in a heartbeat. You are talking about two totally different situations. Brand had a crap team around him based on Krause's idea that he could have a big free agency summer. He had no Hinrich, Deng, anybody like that on his team. Gordon had better teammates, coaches, and a smarter general manager than Brand had while here. That notwithstanding, Brand was a good player here for those two years. And he was just as professional, respectable and hard working as Gordon.
By the way, when someone says "he led...anywhere" I think of franchise players. Gordon led no one nowhere, that was a group of young players who played at a similar level, if anyone led them, it was Skiles...