Is This Video Socially Acceptable?

[Tjodalv]

I'll have to look those albums up again and listen to them. Dark Side forward is usually what I listen to so it has been a while since I've listened to obscured by clouds or meddle. Although now looking at their discography Saucer full of Secrets was pretty good and I think that was Syd Barrett IIRC?

Division Bell was disappointing. It has a few good songs but kind of bordered on pop. I haven't listened to the new one either but have been told it sounds a lot like Division Bell.

Pretty sure the recording/tour of Saucer was the reason they got rid of Barrett (he was "part of the band" but vacant).

I like Division Bell. The thing is that it's an entirely Gilmour band by that point. It really doesn't differ all that much from the earlier Gilmour written material. I have a feeling you're just a Waters devotee (not that there is anything wrong with that [I, obviously, love his solo works.])

Edit: The tour Waters was on when Syd died was easily in my top 5 list of concerts I've ever attended; first set was the entirety of Dark Side and the second set was his solo shit (and he put together a great backing band).

Double edit: It's hard to say that "Coming back to life" wasn't a giant middle finger to Waters concerning his relationship with Barrett http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/pinkfloyd/comingbacktolife.html Those guys must have had one seriously fucked up relationship. Some random psychology grad should write a paper about those nutjobs.

 

[BaBaBlacksheep]

Pretty sure the recording/tour of Saucer was the reason they got rid of Barrett (he was "part of the band" but vacant).

I like Division Bell. The thing is that it's an entirely Gilmour band by that point. It really doesn't differ all that much from the earlier Gilmour written material. I have a feeling you're just a Waters devotee (not that there is anything wrong with that [I, obviously, love his solo works.])

Edit: The tour Waters was on when Syd died was easily in my top 5 list of concerts I've ever attended; first set was the entirety of Dark Side and the second set was his solo shit (and he put together a great backing band).

Double edit: It's hard to say that "Coming back to life" wasn't a giant middle finger to Waters concerning his relationship with Barrett http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/pinkfloyd/comingbacktolife.html Those guys must have had one seriously fucked up relationship. Some random psychology grad should write a paper about those nutjobs.

I saw Waters when he did The Wall a few years ago. Holy shit what a show!

I too liked The Division Bell.

 

[ThatGuyRyan]

Pretty sure the recording/tour of Saucer was the reason they got rid of Barrett (he was "part of the band" but vacant).

I like Division Bell. The thing is that it's an entirely Gilmour band by that point. It really doesn't differ all that much from the earlier Gilmour written material. I have a feeling you're just a Waters devotee (not that there is anything wrong with that [I, obviously, love his solo works.])

Edit: The tour Waters was on when Syd died was easily in my top 5 list of concerts I've ever attended; first set was the entirety of Dark Side and the second set was his solo shit (and he put together a great backing band).

Double edit: It's hard to say that "Coming back to life" wasn't a giant middle finger to Waters concerning his relationship with Barrett http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/pinkfloyd/comingbacktolife.html Those guys must have had one seriously fucked up relationship. Some random psychology grad should write a paper about those nutjobs.

You're right, I do like Waters better. Nothing against Gilmoure, he's awesome. They're both egomaniac assholes though and are talented as hell.