Mike Mayock's Top 5 QB's

[BearClaw55]

They are all pretty crappy prospects.

Im not sure why you think that. It can't be based off their production, arm strength or size. The top two have a 67% & 68% comp percentage.

 

[BearsFan51]

I likely would NEVER draft an Air Raid system QB. Goff was third string behind Keenum and Manion in St. Louis. He couldn't break through those two guys to the head of the depth chart. So I'll pass on Webb and Machines.

 

[Bearly]

Mayock's comments a few weeks ago were kind of ignorant in regards to some of the QB's. His comments about the Trubisky/Williams dynamic didn't really make sense. He had only watched by his own admission 3-5 games of each guy. Another example was his comment about Kizer being "removed" in the USC game comparing it to his temporary benching vs Stanford. Kizer was taken out vs USC so Zaire could get a few final snaps as a senior in a blowout. I think Zaire entered the game with maybe 2 minutes left. His opinions were of a guy who hadn't really deep dove the players yet, and that's fine. These boards might fluctuate a lot more as the process goes forward.

FWIW, Mayock is a guy I really like, respect, and enjoy listening to. He's also very well respected in scout and analyst circles.

My fav of the top talking heads as well and yes, these rankings will vary as we go along. The certainty of posters about where guys will get drafted at this time of year makes me:aj:.

 

[iueyedoc]

I'm a little confused by his rankings this year.

He has Cook in front of Fournette

I agree with this. Fournette has Trent Richardson written all over him.

 

[WindyCity]

I likely would NEVER draft an Air Raid system QB. Goff was third string behind Keenum and Manion in St. Louis. He couldn't break through those two guys to the head of the depth chart. So I'll pass on Webb and Machines.

Legitimate thought.

The lack of success from that system is shocking. Mahomes might have a chance because most of the time those guys don't have his physical tools.

 

[JPPT1974]

DeShaun actually should be at the top there. Barnone!

 

[AussieBear]

I'm a little confused by his rankings this year.

He has Cook in front of Fournette

depends on what you like out of a rb.. cook is a better all around back at this point...

fournette is your classic power back but has that rare track speed/power combo and can catch some...

im taking diesel power/speed over cooks game.. the nfl cant really practice tackling anymore... sooo.. tackling suffers.. plus teams are looking for smaller quicker defenders to defend those aerial focused o's.. bully backs will break them..

 

[WindyCity]

Webb is one of those tireless workers who is first in the door and last out. He progressed throughout the week at the Senior bowl playing very well in the game. You wont have to spend a 1st rounder on him either and can give him time.

What time?

This regime needs to win now and Hoyer sucks.