Sharp at Center

Pez68

Fire Waldron
Joined:
Oct 31, 2014
Posts:
5,020
Liked Posts:
838
Does anyone outside the Blackhawks' organization understand this? Seriously. The guy is absolutely THE BEST option the Hawks have for a #2 center. He has excelled in that role in the past. However, the Hawks REFUSE to play him there. What fucking gives people? THEY WON A FUCKING CUP WITH HIM AS THE 2C!!!



As a hockey player, I just don't understand it. Team has a huge hole. I can fill that huge hole. The only difference is that I work a bit harder, and maybe I put up a few less points. But the team comes out ahead. I jump on that fucking shit 100% of the time.



It is fucking mind boggling. Either Sharp is a fucking asshole who refuses to play center, or the coaching/management of this team is inept. Either way, I fucking hate it. Put that mother ****** at center and solve all the problems this team has.
 

the canadian dream

New member
Joined:
May 15, 2010
Posts:
6,402
Liked Posts:
14
He's injured isn't he? I dont see anyone refusing to play center but Sharps shoulder. I thought the Hawks went on a huge points streak when Sharp was on LW this year? Guess I was dreaming that? Enough of being an ass though...



There are holes on LW too. Its a no win situation.



There is nothing wrong with this team accept 2 huge injuries to 2 key players. Lucky as all **** this team has Kane and Toews on it carrying both their lines and a productive 3rd line (not including tonights game..wasn't very good). Esp Kane because Hayes/Bolland/Kane is a fucking brutal line unless you are wearing Hawk color glasses. Kane carries those two night in and night out and makes it as productive as it can be. Just as he was carrying the line when Sharp was healthy. At least Sharp gives Kanes more options. Hayes doesn't give Kane anything because he can't skate in or into open ice nor does Bolland help Kane much apparently.



If Sharp wants to play center when he comes back then im all for it if Hayes isnt playing LW on that line. Sorry I see Hayes potential with his size but hes a horrible skater and that doesn't work with a guy like Kane. Put Sharp at center you dont have a strong LW. Put Sharp at LW you have a lesser center but at least a 3rd on the line who can skate half decent. Can't win either way. Kane ever gets injured this season then the Hawks are fucked.



Sorry folks. Not won over by Hayes yet just because "he is big" and comes from the farm system. Need more in a skill set. Want Sharp at center when he comes back then find a LW because Sharp/Bolland/Kane is better than Hayes/Sharp/Kane. Anyday. The 3rd line isn't being broken up either and rightfully so. Get over it kids Bolland is this teams 2nd line center unless some deal comes along. A deal I don't think needs to be done. Just get healthy!!
 

Pez68

Fire Waldron
Joined:
Oct 31, 2014
Posts:
5,020
Liked Posts:
838
Huh? Quite obviously I'm talking about the time since the Hawks won the cup. Three years that they have kept Sharp away from center. That's the point. LW are much easier to find than centers, in case you didn't notice.
 

the canadian dream

New member
Joined:
May 15, 2010
Posts:
6,402
Liked Posts:
14
Huh? Quite obviously I'm talking about the time since the Hawks won the cup. Three years that they have kept Sharp away from center. That's the point. LW are much easier to find than centers, in case you didn't notice.



Hawks havent been able to find one since the cup run. So it must be hard esp when cash strapped. Saad has def helped fill parts of the hole so far.



why we talking about the past two seasons? those are done with. The slate is clean in my opinion. **** ups were made and strange decisions are in the past (Kane at center..the mighty speedy Brunnette on LW on the top line). Move on. Sharps fine at LW he isnt fine when on the IR. I find the timing of this thread really strange Pez.
 

Pez68

Fire Waldron
Joined:
Oct 31, 2014
Posts:
5,020
Liked Posts:
838
Harder to find a top six LW than a top six C?
<




Yeah, ok.
 

the canadian dream

New member
Joined:
May 15, 2010
Posts:
6,402
Liked Posts:
14
the timing of this thread is really bizzar pez. Sharps on the IR and you are bitching about him playing a position he is more capable of playing and want him to be playing a position he can't play right now anyways?



I dont understand this thread. sounds like a hang over from last season. seriously...move on. Team is fine (despite a defensive collapse tonight)..team was flying when Sharp was playing LW. Hawks have 4 reg loses on the season. 3 of which have come while Sharp has been out of the lineup completely. 3 which were defensive collapses and arguably a 4th game thanks to one late 3rd period bed shitting. The scoring and offense has NOT been an issue at all this season. Defense really hasn't been either accept in the 4 loses. 4...4 loses....4!!



Really weird thread timing. Just looking to grasp for something to complain about? Just say you hate Bolland and get on with it because that's what this thread is leading too. Its not about Sharp playing center its about Bolland not playing center. Or is this leading to another classic fire Q thread after a 2 game losing streak with 2 top roster players sitting on the IR?



Go find the easy to find LWer Pez if they grow on trees. If its that easy why dont all teams have top scoring LWers on every single one of their lines? I see 6 LWers league wide in the top 30 scoring right now (probably would be 7 had Sharp not separated his shoulder). Good players dont grow on trees and they certainly don't come cheap no matter what position they play. Those who are above the average don't just get thrown around the league like journeymen and are not easy signatures to get when working under a cap. Don't matter the position.



I still don't understand why we have to talk about Sharp playing center when he can't play at all right now anyways. Just weird.
 

PatrickShart

New member
Joined:
May 17, 2010
Posts:
4,782
Liked Posts:
452
Bolland just needs the opportunity at the second line center. Q's been holding him back on the third line shut down center. He was a big time scorer in Jr's....in case you didn't know Pez
 

Pez68

Fire Waldron
Joined:
Oct 31, 2014
Posts:
5,020
Liked Posts:
838
the timing of this thread is really bizzar pez. Sharps on the IR and you are bitching about him playing a position he is more capable of playing and want him to be playing a position he can't play right now anyways?



I dont understand this thread. sounds like a hang over from last season. seriously...move on. Team is fine (despite a defensive collapse tonight)..team was flying when Sharp was playing LW. Hawks have 4 reg loses on the season. 3 of which have come while Sharp has been out of the lineup completely. 3 which were defensive collapses and arguably a 4th game thanks to one late 3rd period bed shitting. The scoring and offense has NOT been an issue at all this season. Defense really hasn't been either accept in the 4 loses. 4...4 loses....4!!



Really weird thread timing. Just looking to grasp for something to complain about? Just say you hate Bolland and get on with it because that's what this thread is leading too. Its not about Sharp playing center its about Bolland not playing center. Or is this leading to another classic fire Q thread after a 2 game losing streak with 2 top roster players sitting on the IR?



Go find the easy to find LWer Pez if they grow on trees. If its that easy why dont all teams have top scoring LWers on every single one of their lines? I see 6 LWers league wide in the top 30 scoring right now (probably would be 7 had Sharp not separated his shoulder). Good players dont grow on trees and they certainly don't come cheap no matter what position they play. Those who are above the average don't just get thrown around the league like journeymen and are not easy signatures to get when working under a cap. Don't matter the position.



I still don't understand why we have to talk about Sharp playing center when he can't play at all right now anyways. Just weird.



Sometimes...you are really dumb. Nothing you just said has anything to do with the topic. The question is simple. Why have the Hawks not put Sharp at center? What the **** does anything you just posted have to do with that question? Nothing. I made the thread because once again trade rumors are starting up. Once again the Hawks' biggest need is center. For the third season in a row, the Hawks are lacking at center, and Sharp plays wing. It just makes no sense.
 

the canadian dream

New member
Joined:
May 15, 2010
Posts:
6,402
Liked Posts:
14
I already told you why. THERE HAVENT BEEN ANY LWERS AND HE IS A SOLID LWER!!! But you don't want to acknowledge that because according to you LWers grow on trees unlike centers and you fail to acknowledge that there has also been a huge hole on LW the last couple years!!!!! LW has actually been just as big as a hole as center. If you think putting Sharp at center doesn't now or wouldnt have in the previous seasons put a bigger hole on LW then we differ on the abilities of guys like Hayes right now. Apparently we have to bring up who the LWers were last 2 season... esp last season. Besides Sharp it was Brunnette, Carcillo, Bickell...OH WHAT AN AMAZING LW DEPTH!!! TOTAL SOLIDITY AT LW!!!! NO HOLES THERE AT ALL!!!! Again thank god Saad is panning out this season or it would have been the same LW problem as last year.



Hes LW this season because Sharp/Bolland/Kane is a shit load better than Hayes/Sharp/Kane on paper AND in by my guess in real life also. THATS WHY!!!! Its not rocket science. Check the team record when Sharp was playing LW before his injury. Maybe when he gets back they will throw him at center and see what Hayes/Sharp/Kane looks like. I doubt it myself unless Bolland gets delt but why would the org make any drastic changes right now? Why do they really have to? This Hawks team healthy can beat any other team in the NHL in a 7 game series. If the Hawks make a deal it's too have injury insurance not to bounce the lines around and **** up the chemistry when this team is healthy.



Who would have played LW last season if Sharp played center? Who Pez..WHO????? Who is a better than Sharp at LW when Sharp returns and decides to play center? Where do you put Bolland if Sharp plays center? 3rd line? The current 3rd lines not being broken up incase you haven't noticed. If you have an issue with that then call Q and tell him he should break up one of the most productive 3rd lines in the NHL.



And again. Why is this topic coming up now? WHY NOW? Why wasn't this discussed when the Hawks were undefeated in regulation with Sharp playing LW and Sharp in the lineup? AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!





You guys are never seem to be happy no matter what the team does nor the teams record. I thought the current record actually showed that the Hawks have been doing the right thing this season and have grown since last season as a team. Guess not.



Oh by the way. Sharp has posted better numbers in the regular season playing LW than he ever did playing center (in less games played even). That might be another reason. As for the playoffs we can discuss that when the Hawks get there again this season. He was certainly bad last year in the playoffs but who was brilliant really? ANOTHER thing he didn't play full time center in 2009-2010 either. Where did that myth brew from? He did play on LW on a lot of of shifts through the reg season and during the cup run just as he did in the 2008-2009 reg season and playoffs also. Remember the Sharp/Toews/Kane line at all? Q has been lucky as all hell to have Sharp on this team and I believe he has used his versatility properly. If you don't think he has then send your resume to the Hawks..im sure they will take a look at it seeing you are a hockey player and all and you are mad.



Only thing I will agree on Sharp is a better overall 2nd line center than Bolland but that doesn't mean Sharp sucks on LW..BECAUSE HE DOESN'T..HE IS ACTUALLY ONE OF THE BETTER LWERS IN THE FUCKING NHL BEING IN THE TOP 25 IN SCORING THE LAST 2 YEARS PROVES THAT!!!. But until you acknowledge who would play LW on the 2nd line and where Bolland gets slotted then this conversation goes nowhere. Personally I think Saad and Sharp are a good 1-2 punch on LW to go along with Hossa and Kane on the RW. I think the coaching staff are correct in this also. Don't worry so much about the 2nd line center. Kane plays a center style off the RW anyways. Its really not as big of a deal as you are trying to make it out to be. When Sharp gets back it gives Kane a guy on the LW to look to who can read the play and find open space also a guy who can control play off the LW when needed (things Hayes can NOT do). Sharp also has center tendencies off the LW so it really isn't a big deal in my opinion if Bollands in the middle of those two. Just thank fucking god Kane isn't playing center this year Because THAT was a nightmare.



But then again I am dumb. I need to go plant my LW tree in my backyard now. Apparently that's how you find them in the NHL.
 

BiscuitintheBasket

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
May 15, 2010
Posts:
3,802
Liked Posts:
0
I already told you why. THERE HAVENT BEEN ANY LWERS AND HE IS A SOLID LWER!!! But you don't want to acknowledge that because according to you LWers grow on trees unlike centers and you fail to acknowledge that there has also been a huge hole on LW the last couple years!!!!! LW has actually been just as big as a hole as center. If you think putting Sharp at center doesn't now or wouldnt have in the previous seasons put a bigger hole on LW then we differ on the abilities of guys like Hayes right now. Apparently we have to bring up who the LWers were last 2 season... esp last season. Besides Sharp it was Brunnette, Carcillo, Bickell...OH WHAT AN AMAZING LW DEPTH!!! TOTAL SOLIDITY AT LW!!!! NO HOLES THERE AT ALL!!!! Again thank god Saad is panning out this season or it would have been the same LW problem as last year.



Hes LW this season because Sharp/Bolland/Kane is a shit load better than Hayes/Sharp/Kane on paper AND in by my guess in real life also. THATS WHY!!!! Its not rocket science. Check the team record when Sharp was playing LW before his injury. Maybe when he gets back they will throw him at center and see what Hayes/Sharp/Kane looks like. I doubt it myself unless Bolland gets delt but why would the org make any drastic changes right now? Why do they really have to? This Hawks team healthy can beat any other team in the NHL in a 7 game series. If the Hawks make a deal it's too have injury insurance not to bounce the lines around and **** up the chemistry when this team is healthy.



Who would have played LW last season if Sharp played center? Who Pez..WHO????? Who is a better than Sharp at LW when Sharp returns and decides to play center? Where do you put Bolland if Sharp plays center? 3rd line? The current 3rd lines not being broken up incase you haven't noticed. If you have an issue with that then call Q and tell him he should break up one of the most productive 3rd lines in the NHL.



And again. Why is this topic coming up now? WHY NOW? Why wasn't this discussed when the Hawks were undefeated in regulation with Sharp playing LW and Sharp in the lineup? AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!





You guys are never seem to be happy no matter what the team does nor the teams record. I thought the current record actually showed that the Hawks have been doing the right thing this season and have grown since last season as a team. Guess not.



Oh by the way. Sharp has posted better numbers in the regular season playing LW than he ever did playing center (in less games played even). That might be another reason. As for the playoffs we can discuss that when the Hawks get there again this season. He was certainly bad last year in the playoffs but who was brilliant really? ANOTHER thing he didn't play full time center in 2009-2010 either. Where did that myth brew from? He did play on LW on a lot of of shifts through the reg season and during the cup run just as he did in the 2008-2009 reg season and playoffs also. Remember the Sharp/Toews/Kane line at all? Q has been lucky as all hell to have Sharp on this team and I believe he has used his versatility properly. If you don't think he has then send your resume to the Hawks..im sure they will take a look at it seeing you are a hockey player and all and you are mad.



Only thing I will agree on Sharp is a better overall 2nd line center than Bolland but that doesn't mean Sharp sucks on LW..BECAUSE HE DOESN'T..HE IS ACTUALLY ONE OF THE BETTER LWERS IN THE FUCKING NHL BEING IN THE TOP 25 IN SCORING THE LAST 2 YEARS PROVES THAT!!!. But until you acknowledge who would play LW on the 2nd line and where Bolland gets slotted then this conversation goes nowhere. Personally I think Saad and Sharp are a good 1-2 punch on LW to go along with Hossa and Kane on the RW. I think the coaching staff are correct in this also. Don't worry so much about the 2nd line center. Kane plays a center style off the RW anyways. Its really not as big of a deal as you are trying to make it out to be. When Sharp gets back it gives Kane a guy on the LW to look to who can read the play and find open space also a guy who can control play off the LW when needed (things Hayes can NOT do). Sharp also has center tendencies off the LW so it really isn't a big deal in my opinion if Bollands in the middle of those two. Just thank fucking god Kane isn't playing center this year Because THAT was a nightmare.



But then again I am dumb. I need to go plant my LW tree in my backyard now. Apparently that's how you find them in the NHL.





Iginla was traded?
 

dlrob315

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
Oct 25, 2010
Posts:
1,153
Liked Posts:
0
Location:
Demolished, No Longer Standing
I already told you why. THERE HAVENT BEEN ANY LWERS AND HE IS A SOLID LWER!!! But you don't want to acknowledge that because according to you LWers grow on trees unlike centers and you fail to acknowledge that there has also been a huge hole on LW the last couple years!!!!! LW has actually been just as big as a hole as center. If you think putting Sharp at center doesn't now or wouldnt have in the previous seasons put a bigger hole on LW then we differ on the abilities of guys like Hayes right now. Apparently we have to bring up who the LWers were last 2 season... esp last season. Besides Sharp it was Brunnette, Carcillo, Bickell...OH WHAT AN AMAZING LW DEPTH!!! TOTAL SOLIDITY AT LW!!!! NO HOLES THERE AT ALL!!!! Again thank god Saad is panning out this season or it would have been the same LW problem as last year.



Hes LW this season because Sharp/Bolland/Kane is a shit load better than Hayes/Sharp/Kane on paper AND in by my guess in real life also. THATS WHY!!!! Its not rocket science. Check the team record when Sharp was playing LW before his injury. Maybe when he gets back they will throw him at center and see what Hayes/Sharp/Kane looks like. I doubt it myself unless Bolland gets delt but why would the org make any drastic changes right now? Why do they really have to? This Hawks team healthy can beat any other team in the NHL in a 7 game series. If the Hawks make a deal it's too have injury insurance not to bounce the lines around and **** up the chemistry when this team is healthy.



Who would have played LW last season if Sharp played center? Who Pez..WHO????? Who is a better than Sharp at LW when Sharp returns and decides to play center? Where do you put Bolland if Sharp plays center? 3rd line? The current 3rd lines not being broken up incase you haven't noticed. If you have an issue with that then call Q and tell him he should break up one of the most productive 3rd lines in the NHL.



And again. Why is this topic coming up now? WHY NOW? Why wasn't this discussed when the Hawks were undefeated in regulation with Sharp playing LW and Sharp in the lineup? AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!





You guys are never seem to be happy no matter what the team does nor the teams record. I thought the current record actually showed that the Hawks have been doing the right thing this season and have grown since last season as a team. Guess not.



Oh by the way. Sharp has posted better numbers in the regular season playing LW than he ever did playing center (in less games played even). That might be another reason. As for the playoffs we can discuss that when the Hawks get there again this season. He was certainly bad last year in the playoffs but who was brilliant really? ANOTHER thing he didn't play full time center in 2009-2010 either. Where did that myth brew from? He did play on LW on a lot of of shifts through the reg season and during the cup run just as he did in the 2008-2009 reg season and playoffs also. Remember the Sharp/Toews/Kane line at all? Q has been lucky as all hell to have Sharp on this team and I believe he has used his versatility properly. If you don't think he has then send your resume to the Hawks..im sure they will take a look at it seeing you are a hockey player and all and you are mad.



Only thing I will agree on Sharp is a better overall 2nd line center than Bolland but that doesn't mean Sharp sucks on LW..BECAUSE HE DOESN'T..HE IS ACTUALLY ONE OF THE BETTER LWERS IN THE FUCKING NHL BEING IN THE TOP 25 IN SCORING THE LAST 2 YEARS PROVES THAT!!!. But until you acknowledge who would play LW on the 2nd line and where Bolland gets slotted then this conversation goes nowhere. Personally I think Saad and Sharp are a good 1-2 punch on LW to go along with Hossa and Kane on the RW. I think the coaching staff are correct in this also. Don't worry so much about the 2nd line center. Kane plays a center style off the RW anyways. Its really not as big of a deal as you are trying to make it out to be. When Sharp gets back it gives Kane a guy on the LW to look to who can read the play and find open space also a guy who can control play off the LW when needed (things Hayes can NOT do). Sharp also has center tendencies off the LW so it really isn't a big deal in my opinion if Bollands in the middle of those two. Just thank fucking god Kane isn't playing center this year Because THAT was a nightmare.



But then again I am dumb. I need to go plant my LW tree in my backyard now. Apparently that's how you find them in the NHL.



tumblr_inline_mf7bpawkRn1qltqg1.gif
 

PatrickShart

New member
Joined:
May 17, 2010
Posts:
4,782
Liked Posts:
452
I already told you why. THERE HAVENT BEEN ANY LWERS AND HE IS A SOLID LWER!!! But you don't want to acknowledge that because according to you LWers grow on trees unlike centers and you fail to acknowledge that there has also been a huge hole on LW the last couple years!!!!! LW has actually been just as big as a hole as center. If you think putting Sharp at center doesn't now or wouldnt have in the previous seasons put a bigger hole on LW then we differ on the abilities of guys like Hayes right now. Apparently we have to bring up who the LWers were last 2 season... esp last season. Besides Sharp it was Brunnette, Carcillo, Bickell...OH WHAT AN AMAZING LW DEPTH!!! TOTAL SOLIDITY AT LW!!!! NO HOLES THERE AT ALL!!!! Again thank god Saad is panning out this season or it would have been the same LW problem as last year.



Hes LW this season because Sharp/Bolland/Kane is a shit load better than Hayes/Sharp/Kane on paper AND in by my guess in real life also. THATS WHY!!!! Its not rocket science. Check the team record when Sharp was playing LW before his injury. Maybe when he gets back they will throw him at center and see what Hayes/Sharp/Kane looks like. I doubt it myself unless Bolland gets delt but why would the org make any drastic changes right now? Why do they really have to? This Hawks team healthy can beat any other team in the NHL in a 7 game series. If the Hawks make a deal it's too have injury insurance not to bounce the lines around and **** up the chemistry when this team is healthy.



Who would have played LW last season if Sharp played center? Who Pez..WHO????? Who is a better than Sharp at LW when Sharp returns and decides to play center? Where do you put Bolland if Sharp plays center? 3rd line? The current 3rd lines not being broken up incase you haven't noticed. If you have an issue with that then call Q and tell him he should break up one of the most productive 3rd lines in the NHL.



And again. Why is this topic coming up now? WHY NOW? Why wasn't this discussed when the Hawks were undefeated in regulation with Sharp playing LW and Sharp in the lineup? AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!





You guys are never seem to be happy no matter what the team does nor the teams record. I thought the current record actually showed that the Hawks have been doing the right thing this season and have grown since last season as a team. Guess not.



Oh by the way. Sharp has posted better numbers in the regular season playing LW than he ever did playing center (in less games played even). That might be another reason. As for the playoffs we can discuss that when the Hawks get there again this season. He was certainly bad last year in the playoffs but who was brilliant really? ANOTHER thing he didn't play full time center in 2009-2010 either. Where did that myth brew from? He did play on LW on a lot of of shifts through the reg season and during the cup run just as he did in the 2008-2009 reg season and playoffs also. Remember the Sharp/Toews/Kane line at all? Q has been lucky as all hell to have Sharp on this team and I believe he has used his versatility properly. If you don't think he has then send your resume to the Hawks..im sure they will take a look at it seeing you are a hockey player and all and you are mad.



Only thing I will agree on Sharp is a better overall 2nd line center than Bolland but that doesn't mean Sharp sucks on LW..BECAUSE HE DOESN'T..HE IS ACTUALLY ONE OF THE BETTER LWERS IN THE FUCKING NHL BEING IN THE TOP 25 IN SCORING THE LAST 2 YEARS PROVES THAT!!!. But until you acknowledge who would play LW on the 2nd line and where Bolland gets slotted then this conversation goes nowhere. Personally I think Saad and Sharp are a good 1-2 punch on LW to go along with Hossa and Kane on the RW. I think the coaching staff are correct in this also. Don't worry so much about the 2nd line center. Kane plays a center style off the RW anyways. Its really not as big of a deal as you are trying to make it out to be. When Sharp gets back it gives Kane a guy on the LW to look to who can read the play and find open space also a guy who can control play off the LW when needed (things Hayes can NOT do). Sharp also has center tendencies off the LW so it really isn't a big deal in my opinion if Bollands in the middle of those two. Just thank fucking god Kane isn't playing center this year Because THAT was a nightmare.



But then again I am dumb. I need to go plant my LW tree in my backyard now. Apparently that's how you find them in the NHL.



That's all I read.
 

Chief Walking Stick

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
May 12, 2010
Posts:
47,886
Liked Posts:
26,376
I heard Iginla trees have ripe fruit come playoff time. I just hope the fruit doesnt fall into Dales lap.
 

PatrickShart

New member
Joined:
May 17, 2010
Posts:
4,782
Liked Posts:
452
The Bolland watch ...



-3 on the year

Off the scoresheet in 17 of 26gms (he's a -10 in those games)

Faceoff percentage - .446 and falling
 

Ton

New member
Joined:
May 14, 2010
Posts:
3,991
Liked Posts:
124
Location:
Park Ridge, IL
Stalberg actually played LW last year. I thought he looked pretty good there.



Saad and Stalberg aren't going to be in the top 30 scorers in the league (yet), but I think they are fairly serviceable as top two LWers. The only problem with this would be the fact that the Hawks would need to blow up their third line, which has been fairly productive this year.



Saad/Toews/Hossa

Stalberg/Sharp/Kane

Bickell/Bolland/Shaw

Hayes/Kruger/Frolik



In theory it looks good (then again, what combination of this roster wouldn't look good?), but we are over halfway done with the year. Is it really necessary to experiment? I think Q has already drawn up the plans, he's not ripping them up now. I think Q has done a good job considering where we stand with a healthy lineup.
 

Pez68

Fire Waldron
Joined:
Oct 31, 2014
Posts:
5,020
Liked Posts:
838
If they pickup a center in a trade, the lines aren't going to stay intact anyway. Unless Bolland is moved as part of that trade.

I already told you why. THERE HAVENT BEEN ANY LWERS AND HE IS A SOLID LWER!!! But you don't want to acknowledge that because according to you LWers grow on trees unlike centers and you fail to acknowledge that there has also been a huge hole on LW the last couple years!!!!! LW has actually been just as big as a hole as center. If you think putting Sharp at center doesn't now or wouldnt have in the previous seasons put a bigger hole on LW then we differ on the abilities of guys like Hayes right now. Apparently we have to bring up who the LWers were last 2 season... esp last season. Besides Sharp it was Brunnette, Carcillo, Bickell...OH WHAT AN AMAZING LW DEPTH!!! TOTAL SOLIDITY AT LW!!!! NO HOLES THERE AT ALL!!!! Again thank god Saad is panning out this season or it would have been the same LW problem as last year.



Hes LW this season because Sharp/Bolland/Kane is a shit load better than Hayes/Sharp/Kane on paper AND in by my guess in real life also. THATS WHY!!!! Its not rocket science. Check the team record when Sharp was playing LW before his injury. Maybe when he gets back they will throw him at center and see what Hayes/Sharp/Kane looks like. I doubt it myself unless Bolland gets delt but why would the org make any drastic changes right now? Why do they really have to? This Hawks team healthy can beat any other team in the NHL in a 7 game series. If the Hawks make a deal it's too have injury insurance not to bounce the lines around and **** up the chemistry when this team is healthy.



Who would have played LW last season if Sharp played center? Who Pez..WHO????? Who is a better than Sharp at LW when Sharp returns and decides to play center? Where do you put Bolland if Sharp plays center? 3rd line? The current 3rd lines not being broken up incase you haven't noticed. If you have an issue with that then call Q and tell him he should break up one of the most productive 3rd lines in the NHL.



And again. Why is this topic coming up now? WHY NOW? Why wasn't this discussed when the Hawks were undefeated in regulation with Sharp playing LW and Sharp in the lineup? AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!





You guys are never seem to be happy no matter what the team does nor the teams record. I thought the current record actually showed that the Hawks have been doing the right thing this season and have grown since last season as a team. Guess not.



Oh by the way. Sharp has posted better numbers in the regular season playing LW than he ever did playing center (in less games played even). That might be another reason. As for the playoffs we can discuss that when the Hawks get there again this season. He was certainly bad last year in the playoffs but who was brilliant really? ANOTHER thing he didn't play full time center in 2009-2010 either. Where did that myth brew from? He did play on LW on a lot of of shifts through the reg season and during the cup run just as he did in the 2008-2009 reg season and playoffs also. Remember the Sharp/Toews/Kane line at all? Q has been lucky as all hell to have Sharp on this team and I believe he has used his versatility properly. If you don't think he has then send your resume to the Hawks..im sure they will take a look at it seeing you are a hockey player and all and you are mad.



Only thing I will agree on Sharp is a better overall 2nd line center than Bolland but that doesn't mean Sharp sucks on LW..BECAUSE HE DOESN'T..HE IS ACTUALLY ONE OF THE BETTER LWERS IN THE FUCKING NHL BEING IN THE TOP 25 IN SCORING THE LAST 2 YEARS PROVES THAT!!!. But until you acknowledge who would play LW on the 2nd line and where Bolland gets slotted then this conversation goes nowhere. Personally I think Saad and Sharp are a good 1-2 punch on LW to go along with Hossa and Kane on the RW. I think the coaching staff are correct in this also. Don't worry so much about the 2nd line center. Kane plays a center style off the RW anyways. Its really not as big of a deal as you are trying to make it out to be. When Sharp gets back it gives Kane a guy on the LW to look to who can read the play and find open space also a guy who can control play off the LW when needed (things Hayes can NOT do). Sharp also has center tendencies off the LW so it really isn't a big deal in my opinion if Bollands in the middle of those two. Just thank fucking god Kane isn't playing center this year Because THAT was a nightmare.



But then again I am dumb. I need to go plant my LW tree in my backyard now. Apparently that's how you find them in the NHL.



Again, I told you why it is being brought up now. LWs, just in the Hawks' system:



Saad

Stalberg

Morin

Bickell

Hayes

Carcillo



Centers?



Toews

Bolland

Shaw

Kruger

....Mayers?



Pretty obvious which position is a need and which is not. Again, I'm not talking about this in regards to this season and moving him NOW. I'm talking about this in regards to the last few seasons...and asking why Sharp has not played center, even when it was desperately needed... Really, how hard is that to understand? I'm not saying the Hawks NEED him to play center RIGHT NOW. I'm just asking why it hasn't happened.



Do the Hawks really think Kane, Frolik, and Kruger are better #2 center options than Sharp? If not, then what is it? It's a fucking mystery, and I am just wondering what everyone's take on it is.
 

nana

New member
Joined:
May 15, 2010
Posts:
662
Liked Posts:
0
I understand the timing. Beyond the trade deadline, I was thinking about this quite a bit at the Kings game and it felt like the Hawks couldn't win a FO unless it was JT. The Hawks are built to be a puck possession team and winning FOs is obviously critical, so whether it is Sharp or someone else, it would be awesome to have a #2C that wins more of them. Yes, the team went on an amazing streak as currently constructed this year, but I think the playoffs are a different animal.
 

Ton

New member
Joined:
May 14, 2010
Posts:
3,991
Liked Posts:
124
Location:
Park Ridge, IL
I understand the timing. Beyond the trade deadline, I was thinking about this quite a bit at the Kings game and it felt like the Hawks couldn't win a FO unless it was JT. The Hawks are built to be a puck possession team and winning FOs is obviously critical, so whether it is Sharp or someone else, it would be awesome to have a #2C that wins more of them. Yes, the team went on an amazing streak as currently constructed this year, but I think the playoffs are a different animal.



Can't deny that.



44-45% isn't going to cut it from Bolland, Shaw, and Kruger. Sharp has taken just over 40 faceoffs this season and is around 58%... 40 faceoffs is a small sample size, but still enough to show that he is capable of being better than 45% consistently.



No center on the trade market right now would help our faceoff numbers. All the speculated centers moving around suck at the dot.
 

bookjones

CCS Donator
Donator
Joined:
May 16, 2010
Posts:
3,869
Liked Posts:
5
Location:
Uptown baby!
Can't deny that.



44-45% isn't going to cut it from Bolland, Shaw, and Kruger. Sharp has taken just over 40 faceoffs this season and is around 58%... 40 faceoffs is a small sample size, but still enough to show that he is capable of being better than 45% consistently.



No center on the trade market right now would help our faceoff numbers. All the speculated centers moving around suck at the dot.



Agreed there's no one on the market per se---a deal needs to be cooked up between 2 GMs to nab one.
 

Top