http://www.chicagotribune.com/sports/football/bears/blog/
Bears mailblog
I know Matt Forte is signed for a couple more years but what are the odds that he retires a Bear? For as important as he is to this team and this offense, I don’t think he’s getting the respect he deserves by not getting the amount of touches necessary to keep the offense on the field and more importantly out of Jay Cutler’s hands. My fear is that when his contract is up with the Bears he’ll go to a team whose only hole to fill is a veteran running back. Is this plausible or is this thinking just an overreaction to how quickly the season has gone south? – Jon R., from email
Forte is signed through next season and unless the Bears sign him to a contract extension before then (I have always maintained a third contract for a running back is a tricky proposition given wear and tear and diminishing production at the position) he will reach the open market. What will the market be for a 29-year-old running back with high mileage? That is impossible to say. Forte has a season and a half to go...READ MORE
Submit your Bears questions Ask Brad Biggs about the Bears
Why can't the experts see Matt Forte's overrated?
Bears running back Matt Forte
Bears running back Matt Forte rushes during the second quarter at Lambeau Field on Sunday. (Nuccio DiNuzzo / Chicago Tribune)
Why don't football commentators, analysts and pundits see the same Matt Forte many fans see. He runs slow, he starts a play in slow motion, he doesn't have ability to shift gears and he can't run through or over anyone. He can't out-run anyone and he doesn't exactly fake anyone out in his moves. Long story short, this guy is sadly overrated and his carries and output as a running back speak for themselves. -- Rich C., Des Plaines, from email
I think you’re really missing the picture here, Rich. Forte might only be outstanding as a back in terms of his ability as a receiver but he’s very good at pretty much everything else, and the combination of those skills makes him a threat in the offense, one that has been ignored too much by Marc Trestman and his coaching staff this season.
Is Forte going to outrun the fast backs in the league? No. Is he going to consistently move the pile on third-and-1? No. Does he look like Barry Sanders in the open field? Who does? He is a smooth runner who...READ MORE
What is Matt Forte's trade value?
Bears running back Matt Forte
Bears running back Matt Forte (22) gets a pat on the back as he heads for the bench during a game against the New England Patriots. (Chris Sweda / Chicago Tribune)
This team has a lot of holes. Would there be a market to trade Matt Forte to a contender for a late first-round or second-round pick next year? -- @plo1921 from Twitter
Now you’re talking about taking the most reliable part of the offense away. I think you’re shooting too high in estimating Forte’s value and that is not meant to knock him at all. He’s far and away the most consistent performer the Bears have on offense and have had for some time. But teams are reluctant to use a first-round pick on running backs in the draft these days. Just because the Colts made a blunder and forked one over to the Browns for Trent Richardson last year doesn’t mean it will happen again.
In fact, that probably heightens caution among general managers when it comes to trading for running backs. Forte turns 29 next month and will be in the final year of his contract next season, meaning his value would be further diminished on the trade market.
Could the Bears fetch a second-round pick for Forte? I...READ MORE
The Bears are bad but are they Abe Gibron bad?
Chicago Bears head coach Abe Gibron
Chicago Bears head coach Abe Gibron (Ed Wagner Jr. / Chicago Tribune)
Sat through horrible 4-12 Abe Gibron teams in 70’s but never saw a team quit like this Sunday. What are your thoughts? -- @tekster420 from Twitter
Off the top? Abe was never quite that bad. The NFL used a 14-game regular season schedule when Gibron was patrolling the sidelines for the Bears and he went 4-9-1 in 1972, 3-11 in 1973 and stayed around to get a third season going 4-10 in 1974.
My second thought is I’m glad I wasn’t around to watch those Bears teams. This Bears team is two wins away from being better than a four-win season and with seven games remaining, that is certainly possible. There is plenty of mediocre to go around in the NFL this season. Hang in there.READ MORE
Should the Bears switch to a 3-4 defense?
Bears defensive end Willie Young
Bears defensive end Willie Young with teammates before a game. (John J. Kim / Chicago Tribune)
With a defense this bad, would it be an easier transition to switch to a 3-4? -- @ZachJackary from Twitter
Good, bad or middle of the road, that has no bearing on the ease with which a team would be able to change schemes. It’s a personnel-based decision and the Bears have very little in the way of personnel right now that would be highlighted in a move to a 3-4. Perhaps it is a consideration down the road if there is a coaching change, but it would require a serious roster turnover.
I don’t see Jared Allen fitting into a 3-4 scheme next season when he is guaranteed $12.5 million. Maybe tackle Ego Ferguson could work in that system but it probably wouldn’t be a match for fellow rookie Will Sutton. I don’t see Willie Young being best used in a 3-4. It would probably best suit Shea McClellin and I’d bet Christian Jones could potentially play it.
People have grasped at the idea of a 3-4 defense for years now and I am not convinced that would solve or necessarily improve a thing. There is...READ MORE
Why not give rookies a shot?
NFL: Miami Dolphins at Chicago Bears
Chicago Bears inside linebacker Christian Jones (59) stops Miami Dolphins wide receiver Jarvis Landry (14) from scoring in the second half of their game at Soldier Field. (Matt Marton / Reuters Photo)
Why not start a few of the rookies? Christian Jones over Shea McClellin, for example. See what the future holds. -- @cush200 from Twitter
Not a bad idea when thinking about the future. Here is what I can tell you about how the coaches think when putting together a plan for player usage: They want the best chance to win this Sunday. Marc Trestman and his staff don’t sit around wondering what can help them on a Sunday in the middle of the 2015 season. They want a lineup that gives them the best chance this Sunday, right now. That is how they’re going to approach it.
It’s worth noting that young players have been getting time, some extensive. Jones has started two of the previous four games and in limited action against the Packers, he showed up. Jones was credited with three solo tackles, two assists and one tackle for loss by coaches after review of game film. He was only on defense for nine snaps. While it was garbage time, this kind of production could lead Jones to be a bigger part of...READ MORE
Cutler to blame for struggles of Trestman's offense?
Miami Dolphins at Chicago Bears
Bears head coach Marc Trestman stands on the sidelines with quarterback Jay Cutler against the Miami Dolphins at Soldier Field. (TANNEN MAURY / EPA)
Marc Trestman's offense has worked everywhere from the NFL to the Canadian Football League and even with Josh McNown. Is is not working this season because defenses have figured it out, or is the fact it's not working the ultimate indictment of Jay Cutler? – Al, Boulder, Colo., from email
I’m not sure we want to equate CFL success to the NFL. The games are a little bit different and certainly the talent is different. I’ve started getting more and more McCown-related questions in the last few weeks and he certainly hasn’t experienced the same level of success with Tampa Bay although it looks like he might be reclaiming the starting job over Mike Glennon.
Cutler continues to make the same type of mistakes in terms of being prone to turnovers from time to time. That’s a major issue. He also hasn’t been able to produce big plays with the same kind of regularity the Bears enjoyed a year ago. The conversation needs to turn from Cutler’s ability and his tools to his production. Ultimately, the...READ MORE
Bears photos24MORE PHOTOS
Week 10: Packers 55, Bears 14
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 10: Packers 55, Bears 14
Bears' Lance Briggs
CHICAGO BEARS
Bears' Lance Briggs
All of the Bears' touchdowns scored this season
CHICAGO BEARS
All of the Bears' touchdowns scored this season
Bears quarterback Jay Cutler
CHICAGO BEARS
Bears quarterback Jay Cutler
Week 8: Patriots 51, Bears 23
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 8: Patriots 51, Bears 23
Week 7: Dolphins 27, Bears 14
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 7: Dolphins 27, Bears 14
Week 6: Bears 27, Falcons 13
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 6: Bears 27, Falcons 13
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 5: Panthers 31, Bears 24
CHICAGO BEARS
Bears wide receiver Brandon Marshall
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 4: Packers 38, Bears 17
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 3: Bears 27, Jets 19
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 2: Bears 28, 49ers 20
CHICAGO BEARS
Week 1: Bills 23, Bears 20 (OT)
CHICAGO BEARS
Rank 'em: Best Bears quarterbacks
CHICAGO BEARS
Bears cornerback Charles Tillman
CHICAGO BEARS
Exhibition: Browns 33, Bears 13
CHICAGO BEARS
Preseason: Seahawks 34, Bears 6
CHICAGO BEARS
Bears backup quarterback Jimmy Clausen
CHICAGO BEARS
New Bears WR Santonio Holmes
CHICAGO BEARS
Preseason: Bears 20, Jaguars 19
CHICAGO BEARS
Preseason: Bears 34, Eagles 28
CHICAGO BEARS
Former Bears QB Jim McMahon
CHICAGO BEARS
Bears Hall of Famer Mike Singletary
CHICAGO BEARS
Richard Dent in action
Are Bears not as bad as they've looked?
Panthers beat bears 31-24
Chicago Bears quarterback Jay Cutler fumbles as he is sacked by Carolina Panthers defensive tackle Kawann Short on the last failed drive of the game at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, N.C. (Chris Sweda / Chicago Tribune)
Is it possible the Bears aren't as bad as they've appeared in the last two weeks? The Dolphins throttled the Chargers 37-0 last Sunday and the Patriots pounded the team having arguably the best first half, the Broncos? – Phil H., Chicago, from email
Sure, that is possible. It's also possible the Bears’ Week 2 victory at San Francisco isn’t quite as impressive as it looked at the time. The 49ers are 4-4. Other than that, the Bears have defeated the Jets and Falcons, who have combined for three wins.
Sometimes in the NFL it isn’t who you play but when you play them. The Bears certainly caught Miami and New England on the upswing, no debating that. The losses that stick out are the opener against the Bills and the Week 5 game at Carolina. The Bears should not have lost to EJ Manual. At Carolina, the Bears had a 21-7 lead and were in the red zone with an opportunity to go up by three touchdowns before halftime. They broke down and never recovered. If this season doesn’t get back on track,...READ MORE
Is Bears' offense better suited to McCown than to Cutler?
ct-spt-1216-dig-bears-cover-3
Chicago Bears quarterback Jay Cutler (6) is congratulated by fellow quarterback Josh McCown (12) after the Bears scored a touchdown in a game last season. (Chris Sweda / Chicago Tribune)
Why doesn't anybody talk about the elephant in the room? That even though the offense was the second-highest scoring unit in the league last year, it truly didn’t take off until Josh McCown got under center? When Jay Cutler was out injured, that was the smoothest I've ever seen a Bears offense play. Yes, McCown has been a washout with Tampa Bay but sometimes quarterbacks find a system that works for them and it elevates their level of play. Marc Trestman’s system fit McCown perfectly. For whatever reason, Cutler just doesn’t get it. – Marshall D., from email
What about Trestman’s system leads Cutler to force balls in the direction of covered receivers and hold the ball at his hip when pressured in the pocket? Those are errors that are leading to turnovers and neither has anything to do with what Trestman is teaching quarterbacks. Cutler has played fine football at times. He hasn’t done so consistently. The Bears made a gamble in diving in with Cutler when they signed him to the contract...READ MORE
Will Jay Cutler's presence keep Bears from drafting a QB?
CT 0815_spt_bears_jaguars_15.JPG
Jay Cutler figures to be the Bears' quarterback for at least the next couple of seasons. (John J. Kim / Chicago Tribune)
I've often argued the Jay Cutler is a good, better-than-average quarterback. Yet, he is in his ninth year and getting no better. His potential is now irrelevant and he is what he is. So, will his guaranteed money now prevent the Bears from drafting a potential franchise quarterback should their abysmal play afford them the draft position to get one? Would the Bears ever admit their mistake and/or eat the money? Even if they would, will the cap hit keep them mediocre for the next four years at least? – Ken P., Chicago, from email
Are the Bears going to eat Cutler’s contract? I dealt with that question last week and I highly doubt it will happen. Will his presence deter them from considering a quarterback high in the draft? Maybe. Maybe not. They certainly are going to have a host of other needs to address. But nothing is more important than the quarterback position and if it’s viewed to be a problem, it would have to be the No. 1 concern. The question is, has doubt creeped into the minds...READ MORE
Are Brandon Marshall's TV trips affecting his play?
ct-spt-1020-bears-dolphins-chicago 2
Chicago Bears wide receiver Brandon Marshall (15) warms up before the game against the Miami Dolphins at Solider Field. (John J. Kim / Chicago Tribune)
Is it time to raise the question of whether Brandon Marshall's weekly trips to New York for the television show may be affecting his focus and his performance? – Garry V., Batesville, Ind., from email
Sure seems to me like this question has been raised on numerous occasions. I don’t know that Marshall’s focus has taken a hit. It’s not like he’s missing time at Halas Hall on his off day. But the production certainly hasn’t been there this season. He’s on pace to have 68 receptions for 768 yards. Not what he or the Bears had in mind. With the ankle injury in the past, I’d expect him to put up better numbers in the second half of the season.
Marshall has done a lot of positive things for the Bears since he arrived. But I’m not sure how the Showtime appearances in New York put football first for him. While it’s impossible to quantify what affect it has on him – if any – it certainly creates questions and with a 3-5 record through the first half of the season, they are unwanted questions to...READ MORE
Will Brock Vereen get a shot at cornerback?
ct-spt-1013-bears-falcons-chicago
Chicago Bears strong safety Brock Vereen watches before a game against the Atlanta Falcons at the Georgia Dome. (Jose M. Osorio / Chicago Tribune)
What are the chances of Brock Vereen getting time at cornerback down the stretch? My thought is he played decently at nickel cornerback and long term, his best position in the NFL might be corner rather than safety. Would make an interesting tandem with Kyle Fuller on the other side. Seems like a better crop of safeties coming out in the draft in 2015 than there was in 2014, which might make it easier to solve that position through next year's draft. -- Joe F., Oswego, Ill., from email
Play Vereen at cornerback and sit Tim Jennings less than a year after he was signed to a lucrative contract extension? No, I don’t think that is going to happen. Vereen lacks the size and strength to be a cornerback on the outside on every down. I’m not sure where he ultimately will fit best It could be at nickel cornerback if he gets some more seasoning and bulks up a little, but I don’t know if that happens this season. The good news is he has been productive on coverage teams and has contributed on...READ MORE