Well first off, you can admit that you were wrong about what i stated, which was in fact starting 5.
And here's my argument, something you have yet to provide in your uninformed basketball "conversations".
Deng>Artest. Deng is younger, provides more offensively, better rebounder and is still a good defender. He's also more of a pro. Artest provides spurts off offense and is just a lockdown defender.Ya Artest is old and has lost the offensive ability he used to have..he is mostly used now for defense..i mean ya he scored 20 pts in game 7 but it wasnt on good shooting...very poor shooter..Deng is nearing his prime and can still give you 18 PPG and 7 RPG and be a good defender despite his recent injuries edge to Deng
Noah>Bynum. Noah is a better defender, passer and runs the court much better. Bynum gets hurt more often and Noah is obviously the leader/heart and soul of this team. His play in the playoffs was superb most of the time. Bynum has more offensive potential though. I love it how people say Bynum is going to be a dominant presence yet he has shown nothing yet..he is way too injury prone and at times he doesnt show up..Noah is definitely more of a leader a better shot blocker,rebounder, offensively noah needs work but at this point his offensive game may STILL be better than Bynum's
Gasol>Boozer. Really no argument here. Gasol went to work on Boozer when they met in the Western Semis and has been one of the best players in these playoffs, period. Gasol is probably one of the if not the best big men in the league probably next to D howard and Timmy, Boozer is a very very very good big man but he isnt on Gasol's level especially since Gasol has incredible footwork and a finesse game as well as his ability to dominate with his height...much better shot blocker than boozer
Kobe>JJ. No argument on this one either. Kobe plays both ends of the floor better than JJ and is a leader. The most clutch player in the league. well duh haha JJ is a very good SG tho..probably a better shooter than kobe..maybe thats it..Kobe is a great defensive as well as offensive player..JJ is fair at defense
Rose>Odom. Doesnt make sense to compare these two considering 1 is a starting PG all-star and the other is a PF 6th man. Thats why we compare starting 5s(original argument). No one can argue who is better whether its Rose-Fisher or Rose-Odom. One of these three is a top player at his position and makes a difference night in and night out.lol Rose vs. Fisher is a joke....Rose would kill the lakers...not that fish isnt a decent player but rose is quite a bit better..having Rose is huge because pg play is the lakers weakness and like rondo rose can break down the lakers d getting to the cup but rose is a better shooter than rondo imo so he can also be somewhat of an outside threat
I see one team with 3 current all-stars(Rose,JJ,Boozer), 1 guy who was in AS discussion until injury and was also considered as most improved and was 2nd in the league in rebounding until injury(Noah). Your 5th and worst player of the 5 is Deng, who is an 18-8 guy who can get to the line and play good defense. Ive never seen a team with a guy that good being their 4th best scoring option and overall 5th best player. I see another team with two All-stars but both are arguably the absolute best at their positions. Then i see a often injured and inconsistent C(Bynum) to go along with one defensive ACE(artest) and one of the leagues most inconsistent athletes(Odom). The Bulls are young and only going to improve. Rose has superstar potential. Kobe is only going to go downhill. Fisher, Odom, Artest are all on the wrong side of their careers. in other words that starting five has little to no weakness all around and is better than the lakers now bench thats debatable depending on what free agents and draft picks would be received in this scenario
The answer is clear. Bulls w/ JJ and Boozer>Lakers. If Kobe and Gasol are off, the Lakers dont stand a chance. If Rose and Boozer are off you still have JJ and Deng.