CSF77
Well-known member
- Joined:
- Apr 16, 2013
- Posts:
- 18,664
- Liked Posts:
- 2,845
- Location:
- San Diego
I don't get this "we can't resign Fowler because Almora is so close" argument. Almora put up a fairly average year in AA this year at a so-so age of 21 so at best you'd argue that he's two years away (2017) and even then, you're trying to project a bat that doesn't have a ton of power in it and a guy who doesn't have a great walk rate to be what exactly? The Cubs are already one of the five best teams in the NL right now and this "get rid of veterans we know are good" argument doesn't sit well with me. The Cubs have needed Fowler's lead-off ability to get themselves 20 over .500 and they don't have anyone in the system who projects to replace that unless you do something drastic like move Schwarber to the lead-off spot.
I think the off-season wish list is back end bullpen arm, a #3 starter clearly better than Hammel, a lefty who gets lefties out, and then giving Schwarber another year platooning C/LF. Considering the Cubs still have another year of arbitration with Coghlan, I say be patient for a year before you start committing to what the 2017-2019 core looks like.
C - Montero, Ross
IF - Rizzo, Baez, LaStella, Castro, Russell, Bryant
OF - Coghlan, Schwarber, Soler, Fowler
Last bat: Alcantra/Sczur/Villaneuva/some cheap FA
That to me makes more sense than trading off guys who still may be good for you. Soler for Kimbrel/Ross or something sounds great but if SD doesn't bite at that, then what? What if Soler rebounds to be closer to 2013 than 2014? What if Schwarber develops a catching ability? What if Almora has peaked? This would leave Joe with a 7/8 man bullpen (if he gets a better third starter he might be more inclined to go with 7 arms) and leave the Cubs some payroll flexibility with regards to their bullpen/3rd starter options.
Basically, I get the idea about wanting to move Schwarber out of the plate but the Cubs have so many good bats/fielders they can put out there if Schwarber is catching that I think one more year to decide what's best makes sense to me. I mean the only guy who will give you more overall C is Posey, that's how good the bat is. And if you open LF for Bryant/Soler to get Baez at 3B, you theoretically improve the offense (Baez/Soler in for Monetro), you improve the 3B defense (Baez over Bryant) and you improve the RF defense (Bryant over Soler).
Almora:
2012: .321/.331/.464 SO%: 9.2% BB%: 1.4%
2013: .329/.376/.466 SO%: 12% BB%: 6.8%
2014: .270/.291/.392 SO%: 13.6% BB%: 2.8%. He fell out of favor this year. Rightfully so.
2015: .287/.323/.416 SO%: 11.6% BB%: 7.9%
So this year he bounced back. The big change was hit BB% jumping up 5% from last year. Add to it his D is top end for CF. Takes the best routes. Solid skills all around.
He has always had the highest floor of the big 4.