id say the AKME regime has been worse by a long shot than the GarPax regime. At least the GarPax regime drafted well and put a competitive product on the court
If we take the GarPax regime to be from 2009 (when Gar became GM officially) to 2020 when Gar was fired, I'd give them credit for the following picks who were not busts or otherwise terrible:
2009 - Taj Gibson
2009 - James Johnson (solid role player who's actually still in the league believe it or not, but only became good in his role after leaving the Bulls)
2011 - Jimmy Butler
2015 - Bobby Portis (again, better once he left Chicago...only really became "good" in his role in Milwaukee)
2017 - Lauri Markkanen (again better after leaving Chicago)
2018 - Wendell Carter Jr (I don't actually think he's that good, but he doesn't suck so for the sake of argument I'll credit him)
2019 - Coby White (arguably Gar lucks out here as he has had basically no input on Coby's development and you could credit it more to AK's hiring of BD)
2019 - Daniel Gafford (decent role player, again better once out of Chicago)
If we're talking about players who GarPax drafted who actually played well in a Bulls uniform, you got Taj and Jimmy and that's it. Coby too if you want to be generous. Portis, Markkanen, and WCJ all had flashes here, but they all got better after leaving and one can say that is due to the system GarPax put in place actually holding them back.
Now I'm not saying AK is any better (so far his only true hit is Ayo, albeit small sample size). I'm just saying the GarPax era of drafting wasn't actually all that great.
Now in terms of fielding a competitive product, yes I will give GarPax the win on that as from post DRose injury until 2017 when Jimmy was traded, those teams were still more competitive with arguably a similar talent level to what AK has assembled today. Though AK also gets the blemish of we'll never know how this team would have looked with Lonzo healthy the last couple years and I believe Lonzo was absolutely essential to the plan of this roster construction. Nevertheless, a team with this much offensive talent shouldn't be a bottom 3rd tier team, so win goes to GarPax easily here.
All this to say, if we gave AK a 10-11 year window like we gave GarPax, I don't think the end result would actually be that much worse. Perhaps definitely worse, but not landslide worse. But maybe we'll never know.