Ban bet.

[Novak]

So are you doing it by qb rating or not? Or you could do TDs, yards, and ints.. he has to finish top 12 in 2 out of the 3.

 

[Desperado34]

We already stated this is a run first team so yardage isn't fair.

 

[Desperado34]

I think he'll qb rating will be top 12 overall. Is that a good accumulation of stats that are fair?

 

[Novak]

Then just do QB rating... unless u don't think that is fair either.

Nothing is fair

 

[Desperado34]

12 is not elite. Elite is top 4-5.

Cutler would be in that if he was in Arians offense

 

[airtime143]

If I were making the rules on this, I would say top 12 would be all of the below-

1. 12th ranked passer rating or better (with him having over 400 attempts and all others having over 400 attempts- that is 25 per game, 16 games, and it level the playing field. I think the "2 or more games missed" rule will kill the ban bet- it muddies the water. what if he fails to finish several games? What if other QBS fail to finish several games? 400+ pass attempts is a big enough body of work to judge a season IMO)

2. Top 12 in td-int ratio. (among qbs with 400+ attempts)

3. top 12 in completion percentage (among QBs with 400+ attempts)

4. a bare minimum requirement of a 2-1 td to int ratio.



Personally, I think the big issue on this ban bet is that the parameters seem too lose on both sides.

 

[Desperado34]

Why not top 12QBR?

 

[Mitchapalooza]

Cutler would be in that if he was in Arians offense

shut the fuck up ramblin34

 

[Desperado34]

shut the fuck up ramblin34

Why don't you run your mouth more and get in on this bet?

 

[airtime143]

Why not top 12QBR?

Because it is way to friggin subjective- that is broken down and factored play by play with really loose rules.

Cutler would benefit greatly from some of their parameters, but the fumbles would wreck him on that as well. seems way too loosy goosey.

 

[Desperado34]

Derail thread, someone ban Johnny. We're trying to figure this out

 

[Mitchapalooza]

Why don't you run your mouth more and get in on this bet?

this is GPP's bet. Come up with another bet and maybe I'll take it.

 

[Desperado34]

Because it is way to friggin subjective- that is broken down and factored play by play with really loose rules.

Cutler would benefit greatly from some of their parameters, but the fumbles would wreck him on that as well. seems way too loosy goosey.

Touché. But why would injuries factor in? That's fair for both of us. I wouldn't win if cutler is injured but won stats wise, vice versa.

 

[Desperado34]

this is GPP's bet. Come up with another bet and maybe I'll take it.

This is an open bet. Bet you Bears go 9-7 at the least

 

[Mitchapalooza]

This is an open bet. Bet you Bears go 9-7 at the least

they probably will go 9-7. they have the easiest schedule in the league.

 

[Desperado34]

they probably will go 9-7. they have the easiest schedule in the league.

If you can't provide valuable feedback just ignore this thread.

 

[Mitchapalooza]

If you can't provide valuable feedback just ignore this thread.

the irony is strong with this comment.

 

[Novak]

I'll bet you that Cutler doesn't finish with a 2:1 td to int ratio.

 

[Desperado34]

I'll bet you that Cutler doesn't finish with a 2:1 td to int ratio.

Again it's been stated the Bears will be a run first team.

 

[Novak]

Again it's been stated the Bears will be a run first team.

That really has zero bearing on ratios... I don't think you understand how ratios work