Carcillo

[R K]

Flyers fans loved him. I'm sure he's bummed he's hurt and suspended.

 

[MassHavoc]

Last thing we want to do is be like flyers fans....

 

[BigPete]

They are still going to pay for his 'repairs' thought, right? If it was you or I we would be paying that out of pocket once our insurance ran out. Correct me if I'm wrong but they don't have that same situation.

 

[BigPete]

Flyers fans loved him. I'm sure he's bummed he's hurt and suspended.

Flyers fans beat up off duty cops that were war veterans.



Did you guys here about that one yet?

 

[IceHogsFan]

I'd like Carcillo to stay on the Hawks, less risk of hurting his own players with bonehead plays. And I, stupidly perhaps, think he could improve and just become a hard-nosed pest instead of a moron.

I miss Fraser.

 

[EspoForever]

I'd like Carcillo to stay on the Hawks, less risk of hurting his own players with bonehead plays. And I, stupidly perhaps, think he could improve and just become a hard-nosed pest instead of a moron.

When we first signed this guy I wretched, but then decided to give him a chance. However, he was just suspended 2 months ago for taking a guy into the end wall (and, yes, he deserved that one too) and go out and do something similar but WORSE 60 days later, I am afraid there is no fix for that level of stupid.



Not to mention all the DUMBASS penalties he takes...most recent one I remember is inside the last 2 minutes of a tied game on Long Island he decided to punch a guy well after the whistle. The agitator role is supposed to agitate OTHER people into being stupid, not BE THE ONE taking the dumb penalty!

 

[R K]

Flyers fans beat up off duty cops that were war veterans.



Did you guys here about that one yet?

I just read about it. He didn't stand up and say "I'm an off duty Cop" or "I'm an Iraq war hero". That shit happens everywhere. It's dumb, drunk fans.



How about the guy beaten outside the Giants stadium last year? Or the Bruins fan beaten in the street of Vancouver? It happens everywhere.

 

[jakobeast]

I had heard his suspension starts tonight as well. If he hasn't been put on the IR then it makes sense. I think it may be shitty, but if I was the book keeper for the organization or any business, it is a good move, fiscally.



Remember Fleury? The Hawks did some fancy stuff to get rid of him.

 

[jakobeast]

I just read about it. He didn't stand up and say "I'm an off duty Cop" or "I'm an Iraq war hero". That shit happens everywhere. It's dumb, drunk fans.



How about the guy beaten outside the Giants stadium last year? Or the Bruins fan beaten in the street of Vancouver? It happens everywhere.

I hate the Flyers only because their fans. **** them.

 

[Variable]

Klemmer, I would agree with you if these suspensions were for on ice incidents, but only one was, the one this year, which wasn't really worth a suspension at all.

How do you define on ice incidents? Because to me, there's more than just one on ice incident:



Sucker punching Bradley before he got his gloves off to fight

Punching Talbot at the end of a game during a face off

Pitkanen hit, like it or not, it was a dumb, dangerous play

Cross checking Clarkson in the face

Hit on Gilbert



These are just the things that are caught. You know there have to be other incidents that he hasn't been fined for which now he might be. He's a dumb player, he makes dirty plays. Not to mention his embellishing, completely faking being hurt by a high stick and then arguing it. **** him. He made his reputation, that's him doing those things, not any ref, there's no one else to blame for that but him. He's gotten what he deserves. Yes he is a target, rightfully so by his actions and behavior. Of course they will be watching him closer than other players, because he still hasn't learned. You can't expect the benefit of the doubt for this guy, he hasn't earned it. Probably never will, and that's all on him.

 

[R K]

I had heard his suspension starts tonight as well. If he hasn't been put on the IR then it makes sense. I think it may be shitty, but if I was the book keeper for the organization or any business, it is a good move, fiscally.



Remember Fleury? The Hawks did some fancy stuff to get rid of him.

Completely different situation. Fleury's issue was more so with the NHL directly. He voilated the substance abuse policy, twice.

 

[R K]

I hate the Flyers only because their fans. **** them.

Yea they have shitty fans. So does St. Louis. Big deal. That building is a great place to watch a hockey game.

 

[Chief Walking Stick]

How do you define on ice incidents? Because to me, there's more than just one on ice incident:



Sucker punching Bradley before he got his gloves off to fight

Punching Talbot at the end of a game during a face off

Pitkanen hit, like it or not, it was a dumb, dangerous play

Cross checking Clarkson in the face

Hit on Gilbert



These are just the things that are caught. You know there have to be other incidents that he hasn't been fined for which now he might be. He's a dumb player, he makes dirty plays. Not to mention his embellishing, completely faking being hurt by a high stick and then arguing it. **** him. He made his reputation, that's him doing those things, not any ref, there's no one else to blame for that but him. He's gotten what he deserves. Yes he is a target, rightfully so by his actions and behavior. Of course they will be watching him closer than other players, because he still hasn't learned. You can't expect the benefit of the doubt for this guy, he hasn't earned it. Probably never will, and that's all on him.

I speed constantly without getting caught... so should the cops factor in all of the times I haven't been caught if I do get pulled over?

 

[R K]

I can't believe they gave you a fucking drivers license in the first place. Then again this is Illinois after all. Any ****** bag can drive from the age they can touch the pedals.

 

[jakobeast]

Completely different situation. Fleury's issue was more so with the NHL directly. He voilated the substance abuse policy, twice.

I am not saying its the same situation. I am just saying the Hawks made him and his contract disappear. I know they are different things, just citing an example of fancy book keeping.

 

[the canadian dream]

**** you carcillo you cost the Hawks the game tonight against the Flyers by not being there.



Asshole!!!!



you also made Sopel cry.

 

[Chief Walking Stick]

Scottberg.... **** you too for being scratched for O'donnelberg who is WORSE!!



Scott and Carcillo's fault!!!!!

 

[the canadian dream]

Im actually wondering why Scott was scratched. I really think he actually has helped the blueline in our own zone. O'Donell? not so much.



Its strange to say and its strange to feel but i think its actually true Scott is a better defenseman than O'Donell.

 

[Chief Walking Stick]

Im actually wondering why Scott was scratched. I really think he actually has helped the blueline in our own zone. O'Donell? not so much.



Its strange to say and its strange to feel but i think its actually true Scott is a better defenseman than O'Donell.

That's because he is.... last year I would have said NO WAY! But you can really tell how hard Scott worked in the offseason to become a better player.



I was just surprised he was scratched against a team like the Flyers which is one of the teams I figured Q would dress him for.



Oh well... he wouldn't have had an outcome on the game anyways.

 

[jakobeast]

Scott is better then OD. Fact.