Top defenses? Recently? The Saints were in one of the worst divisions in football. This past year the Saints defense finished near the bottom when a couple teams in the division played well. His defenses are good against bad teams.
HC experience at being terrible. He’s a terrible HC.
Football like life, surround yourself with winners.
I am not evaluating him as HC, as he isn't in that role. But HC experience won't be a negative for a DC.
He was DC in N.O. for 7 seasons. He took over in NO as DC and had the 32nd ranked D. Within 2 years, Top 10. 5 years in a row 14th or better, 3 of those Top 10.
You're looking at the Saints in his time as HC, when he took over for a HC who quit when his HOF QB retired. Whose record would be great without a QB?
You say the division sucks but you're looking at it in 2024, not when he was DC.
2015 Carolina was 15-1.
2016 Atlanta went to the Super Bowl
2017 three teams won 10 or more
And the claim that team's season-long stats are all based on division games is silly, given that division games account for 6 of 16/17.
Last two years his D was Top 5. I will take that. Nobody is claiming he's the best ever. But I am not sure who is available as a candidate that is better.