Has Hammel ever made an All Star game? Put together a couple more gems without a dud and he's gotta get some consideration.
He has not. As for him making it, I'd like to believe he can but if I'm being honest I don't know if that's the case. You're just going to have a bunch of guys get in on name alone. Last year in terms of pitching you had the following
Starters
Clayton Kershaw
Alfredo Simon
Zack Greinke
Adam Wainwright
Relievers
Tony Watson
Craig Kimbrel
Aroldis Chapman
Tyler Clippard
Pat Neshek
Francisco Rodriguez
So, you're likely only talking about 4-5 starters max. Scherzer is a lock. Gerrit Cole probably should be. So then you got a list of guys like Shelby Miller, Zack Greinke, Kershaw, Michael Wacha, Matt Harvey, Arrieta, Jordan Zimmermann, Jacob deGrom, Madison Bumgarner....etc. And the thing Hammel doesn't have going for him is Rizzo almost assuredly makes the all star team. So given you have to take one guy from each team that starts to make this more difficult.