26 to 28 is still less than a 1 to 1 TD to Int ratio which is terrible. The claim wasnt that it wad identical to Fields. You claim was that good QBs still put up good stats. 28 ints is not good. His first 2 years starting Brees had more Ints than TDs and a passer rating lower than Fields in one of those years. So as a matter of objective fact, you assertion is wrong.
I am sure you are aware that Ints are not always on the QB. Your opinion here is no less hypothetical. The only difference is PFF gets paid for their hypotheticals while you do not.
For years you were ignoring stats to defend Trubisky so it is amusing that all of a sudden you only want to rely on stats.
Your trying to compare a QB from 23 years ago with the rules back then to now? just stop
Also I said that good QBs have good stats in response to you saying "No one evaluates QBs just based on hard stats." (and then you went into hypothetical stats to evaluate Fields lol)
The point that you are failing with comparing Manning (other then the rules are now more pro offense) is that yes Manning didnt have good stats his rookie year due to his INT.. BUT he showed that he had promise due to his TD, yards, completion% etc.. Rookies generally dont have great stats but there is some great stats mixed in with the bad that shows something is there to build off of
Fields has nothing to counter his bad INT stat.. its ALL, marginal, bad and horrible. there is nothing in Fields stats that shows anything close to what Manning showed.. again just stop.. lets compare him to a more recent QB in a very similar situation that is also in todays NFL.. someone like Mitch Trubisky?
When the bar is set at Mitch Trubisky rookie year, a VERY VERY VERY low bar.. and he has failed to even live up to that? Thats a problem.. a big problem.
You want to say that you think he will get better and blow away Mitch then thats great. I hope your right.. but thats another discussion. What I'm talking about is reality and sorry but the reality is Jones is the better QB (RIGHT NOW) as is comparing rookie Mitch to Fields right now..
So with the info we have (RIGHT NOW) it shows that pace made the wrong pic.. and should be fired (RIGHT NOW)