I picked the first line but let me clarify.
I believe Caleb Williams will be a better QB in the NFL than Justin Fields. I feel he can grasp the mental part better than Fields after NFL coaching. So with that, I think he gives us the best chance to make more plays to win games.
Now, whatever Poles decides, I’m good with it. Because in my opinion, you can win with both. You just need a great defense with Fields since there will be missed opportunities offensively with him at helm. Kind of like 2006. Fields just gives you that extra help with his legs. You can win that way.
With Caleb, I think you can win with a good (not great) defense. More will be put on the offensive side to score, which once he has settled, I think he can do with the rest of his team. More like the Chiefs, Bengals, and Bills way.
Which way do I prefer and what I think gives us more of a chance to win, the way with Caleb at helm. But you can with both ways. Just need to coaching staff to know that and play within the strengths of the team.