Fields vs Williams comparison

[knoxville7]

Justin Fields Stats From 9/26/2021 To 10/17/2021 | StatMuse

Justin Fields had a passer rating of 72.6 with 562 yards, 2 touchdowns and 2 interceptions in 4 games between September 26, 2021 and October 17, 2021.

www.statmuse.com

more appropriate
View attachment 40927

ruh roh raggy!!! thats 0.6 points higher than CW's!!!

cue the sky falling!!

 

[jc456]

You: That says it all
Me: No it doesn’t
You: It will!!!!

Fucking

so here's Beast genius who doesn't know statistics, they don't lie.

 

[msadows]

caleb has a 5.6yards per attempt, that puts him in the same category as the great jacoby brisket

 

[msadows]

caleb is a bottom 5 qb in the nfl thru the first 4 weeks. Hopefully by week 12 he's at least in the top 20, otherwise this message board might have a meltdown.

 

[Pez68]

Awesome. Just what this forum was missing. Another Fields vs. Williams discussion.

Thanks!

 

[RPMcMurphy47]

If CW isn't miles better than the bears version of Fields by year 2 and/or 3 then we have a major problem. There shouldn't be a comparison down the line or he'd be kind of an epic bust.

 

[Beast15]

caleb is a bottom 5 qb in the nfl thru the first 4 weeks. Hopefully by week 12 he's at least in the top 20, otherwise this message board might have a meltdown.

We already have, bro.

 

[msadows]

If CW isn't miles better than the bears version of Fields by year 2 and/or 3 then we have a major problem. There shouldn't be a comparison down the line or he'd be kind of an epic bust.

Fields could also develop under the steelers.

He looks much more confident on the steelers than I ever saw him with the bears. It was never a lack of talent, it was just a lack of being able to play QB.

We already have, bro.

Nah, I troll the kid but most people still have hopes that are sky high, including me. Its 4 games, but if he's still throwing under 6 Yards Per Attempt by week 8-10 then I think we have a problem. I think he understands and reads the coverages very well for how early he is in his career but the lack of accuracy is extremely concerning

 

[number51]

Williams looks pretty good for a rookie. I am hoping that next season he will have a quality coaching staff to work with. I wish nothing but the best for former Bear JF.

 

[msadows]

Williams looks pretty good for a rookie. I am hoping that next season he will have a quality coaching staff to work with. I wish nothing but the best for former Bear JF.

5.6 yards per attempt seems to be good for bears fans

 

[number51]

5.6 yards per attempt seems to be good for bears fans

Try to use both of your brain cells. I said Williams looks pretty good for a rookie. I expect him (and all rookies) to improve with time and coaching.

 

[msadows]

Try to use both of your brain cells. I said Williams looks pretty good for a rookie. I expect him (and all rookies) to improve with time and coaching.

Thus far he's looked like shit for a QB, rookie or not.

 

[Noonthirtyjoe]

I expect HOF play starting week 10. These things take time.

 

[msadows]

I expect HOF play starting week 10. These things take time.

Week 10 is when i start calling him caleb trubisky

 

[Noonthirtyjoe]

Week 10 is when i start calling him caleb trubisky

Owch lets hope not.

 

[Les Grossman]

5.6 yards per attempt seems to be good for bears fans

You should probably take that up with the OC

 

[TheEarlofRobin]

ruh roh raggy!!! thats 0.6 points higher than CW's!!!

cue the sky falling!!

Good use of the Rex Grossman clip

 

[TheEarlofRobin]

You should probably take that up with the OC

Yes, because the OC keeps calling those "throw the ball 10 yards past the open WR" plays.

 

[tcmtrinity]

I was interested in it since everything I have seen has been Fields with 4 seasons vs Williams with 4 starts... so I dug up some data on rookie vs rookie. Honestly, I was and still on the fence of one vs the other but interesting none the less.

Justin Fields Rookie Stats First 4 Games | StatMuse

Justin Fields had a passer rating of 53.9 with 347 yards and 2 interceptions in 4 games in his first 4 games in his rookie season in 2021.

www.statmuse.com

View attachment 40902

Caleb Williams Rookie Stats First 4 Games | StatMuse

Caleb Williams has a passer rating of 72.0 with 787 yards, 3 touchdowns and 4 interceptions in 4 games in his first 4 games this season.

www.statmuse.com

View attachment 40903

I believe you must manage your time
very well to have enough time in your life to engage in this research. Kudos to your time
management skills, I say.

 

[msadows]

Yes, because the OC keeps calling those "throw the ball 10 yards past the open WR" plays.

Or check down to swift 10 times a game

Waldron actually is scheming a lot of downfield plays, gayleb is just missing them.

Think I heard on ESPN 1000 from waddle yesterday that he's 12/42 on throws of 10+ yards for 1td and 3 ints. Thats dogshit, rookie or not rookie.

That must be on the OC too, lol.