Former Jets scout calls Caleb Williams the most mentally weak prospect he's ever seen - says he's closer to Johnny Manziel than Patrick Mahomes

[BaBaBlacksheep]

Dude has Caleb Williams projected as a 4th round QB.

Here's his rankings for the draft.
Rattler
Penix
Milton III
Nix
Maye
Daniels
Williams.

Most obvious post BS for clicks list I’ve seen in a while.

 

[Discus fish salesman]

Dude has Caleb Williams projected as a 4th round QB.

Here's his rankings for the draft.
Rattler
Penix
Milton III
Nix
Maye
Daniels
Williams.

He should be embarrassed. Ranking Milton above all those guys is a joke. He does have a strong arm though

 

[bamainatlanta]

Dude has Caleb Williams projected as a 4th round QB.

Here's his rankings for the draft.
Rattler
Penix
Milton III
Nix
Maye
Daniels
Williams.

Yeah this is quite the take. The “former” scout is going for some edge lord cringe angle

 

[Bearly]

View attachment 34492

Fuck you're weird.

 

[Bearly]

Yeah this is quite the take. The “former” scout is going for some edge lord cringe angle

When one of the later picks looks better than one of the 1st rounder, he'll pound that harder than MJY while ignoring all the fails.

 

[DavidH]

oh this is that fan turned scout we heard this from a few weeks ago who scouted for the jets for a few years like 20 years ago

 

[iueyedoc]

Yeah this is quite the take. The “former” scout is going for some edge lord cringe angle

Thank you for "former" scout.
Like if an pilot loses his wings and is fired for incompetence and has a blog where he talks about airplanes is he somehow still a pilot?

 

[Bearly]

oh this is that fan turned scout we heard this from a few weeks ago who scouted for the jets for a few years like 20 years ago

I'll give you one guess what position he never evaluated.

 

[dennehy]

Reading the quotes in the article - it doesn't sound like this Jets scout has had any real facetime with CW and is just reading between the lines. He doesn't actually know CW and he cites



Is this not what every #1 overall pick has to face?

This is nothing more than some fluff piece by a scout to tarnish Williams. It happens every year with draft picks. Like when the story broke about Fields and his epilepsy that ends up never being an issue. This is why teams go through the scouting process, interview players, coaches, teammates and host them on visits. The scout may be right, but without first hand experience with CW it's much of nothing.

Even with first hand experience, you never know. The people whose opinions matter don't say anything about their thoughts on a player publicly. Perhaps they might anonymously.

 

[mecha]

GOODBYE

say hello to the HeHateMe Kliq for me. thanks

 

[msadows]

This scout thought that Mark Sanchez was the next mark anthony.

 

[Bearly]

Thank you for "former" scout.
Like if an pilot loses his wings and is fired for incompetence and has a blog where he talks about airplanes is he somehow still a pilot?

Don't be psilocybin.



Not you, the pilot.

​

 

[Zvbxrpl]

The same Jets scout who wants to be a future GM but wrote a Q&A article about why Erin Rodgers won’t be a jet, a couple weeks before the trade?

The same scout that called Zach Wilson ‘generational’ and that the jets are failing him?

The same guy who’s out of a job in the scouting world now?

Yeah, that’s a guy who you should take his word as gospel.

 

[Discus fish salesman]

say hello to the HeHateMe Kliq for me. thanks

WUT

 

[msadows]

The same Jets scout who wants to be a future GM but wrote a Q&A article about why Erin Rodgers won’t be a jet, a couple weeks before the trade?

The same scout that called Zach Wilson ‘generational’ and that the jets are failing him?

The same guy who’s out of a job in the scouting world now?

Yeah, that’s a guy who you should take his word as gospel.

Its not that challenging to be an NFL scout, you just need to know people. You can be football stupid, tbh.

Look at greg gabriel, dude was head of player personnel and guy is brane dead.


I've actually seen more idiot takes from "former" nfl scouts than anywhere else.

 

[Frequency]

say hello to the HeHateMe Kliq for me. thanks

I thought a Kliq was for vaginas...

 

[DefNextYear]

I'll loosely call this guy a "former scout". He did a couple of years 2 decades ago.

https://www.linkedin.com/in/daniel-kelly-54b56218a

 

[modo]

This is the thread we needed, but don't deserve.

 

[Bearly]

Its not that challenging to be an NFL scout, you just need to know people. You can be football stupid, tbh.

Look at greg gabriel, dude was head of player personnel and guy is brane dead.


I've actually seen more idiot takes from "former" nfl scouts than anywhere else.

It's not like any of them decide anything and are simply a another reference point for the GM. More about finding diamonds in the rough and later rounds. Poles and Cunningham will personally review every player in the top 100 and most in the top 200 plus later round scout recommendations.

 

[BaBaBlacksheep]

Its not that challenging to be an NFL scout, you just need to know people. You can be football stupid, tbh.

Look at greg gabriel, dude was head of player personnel and guy is brane dead.


I've actually seen more idiot takes from "former" nfl scouts than anywhere else.

Greg retweeted this guy’s CW rant too.