10veitout
Active member
- Joined:
- Mar 11, 2013
- Posts:
- 4,721
- Liked Posts:
- 344
I am honestly telling you that are you so entirely full of shit and so obviously making everything up as you go along (like Jalen Hurts as a 6'2 version of Russell Wilson....lol) that I do not know what you mean. That is correct, I am honestly baffled by your inability to even guess correctly at the profile of these players.
I'm
Except our threshold for acceptable quarterback play is not "better than Mitch Trubisky" since "better than Mitch Trubisky" applies to quite a few other shitty quarterbacks who I dont want. You want to argue that body of work Minshew is better than Trubisky? Fine, whatever. It's like arguing over which kind of cancer is best to have. Fact is the Bears are hunting for the answer at the quarterback position, not a bunch of new questions. Gardner Minshew solves nothing, and his absence from the Bears roster is absolutely not worth losing our minds over.
As for your weird obsession with statistics, I dont know what it has to do with a comparison between the Bears defense and Green Bay's defense? I would say they are about equal, Green Bay has better top end talent (for instance ZD Smith > Khalil Mack) but overall the Bears have fewer defensive decencies. It probably cancels out, though obviously whatever the Packers are doing is working much better than whatever the Bears are doing so maybe that's your tiebreaker. But, to bring this discussion into some sort of relevance with our conversation....nothing in the NFL happens in a vaccum. Success is contingent on dozens of factors outside an individual players' control. And for that reason statistics are generally worthless.
I never said Minshew was great, I said he was worth lamenting that you missed out on him. Which is true, him having a bad stretch and getting benched doesnt change that he has a great career TD to INT ratio and a good rating on an awful team.
Your saying that on field production has no bearing on how we judge players. That's literally too stupid to fathom lol. We have no other way to judge players then by individual production, we simply must keep it in context with everyone else on their teams individual production as well,.