I disagree with this. I'm a Maddon guy but if the Cubs did move on Girardi would be my choice. Dude didn't have a losing record in ten years and a lot of that stuff that came out about not using analytics and having a hard time with young players literally came out of the blue when he was let go. The Yankees moved on because they didn't want to pay a manager $5 mil per and they embellished to justify it. As a player Girardi was one of the early proponents of using analytics to prepare and if you listen to him speak on it he has a solid grasp and is very supportive of the approach. As far as young players, maybe he's better with veterans but other guys that played for him as young players disputed the Yankees assertions. The guy just wins. A year ago I would have had the Joes neck and neck and 3-4 as far as the best managers in the game.