Try to follow along. Irsay is calling the shots now as he is fed up.
“I think it’s dangerous when owners try and impose their will,” he once cautioned. But over the coming weeks, as the season continued to crumble, Irsay told himself something else.
“To hell with that.”
After a Week 6 road loss to the Titans — the team Irsay hates to lose to more than any other — the owner stepped in, pushing Reich to change quarterbacks late that night. A day later, the coach reluctantly announced the decision to bench Ryan for Sam Ehlinger. Ryan’s shoulder separation was real, but not serious, and the Colts went out of their way to stress the move wasn’t injury-related. Reich couldn’t flat-out reveal that Irsay made the call — given the choice, the coach would’ve gone with Nick Foles before Ehlinger — but as he tiptoed around that reality, Reich offered a lens into what their discussions had been like the night before.
“He’s a one-man crew,” the coach said of Irsay’s influence.
Where did Ballard stand on all of this? His hands were dirty, no doubt. This was the team he put together, and it had crumbled from preseason AFC South favorites into one of the worst in the league.
Did his voice still matter? Irsay had gone above him on three consecutive franchise-altering decisions: moving Wentz, benching Ryan and hiring Saturday. Did the owner still trust him? As one former team employee wondered, “At what point does Ballard just quit?”
Irsay wants a quarterback with the team’s top pick, but he knows how dangerous that thinking can be. “You can’t force it at that position,” he’s admitted. Irsay’s tired of the veteran QB carousel, scarred by the misses on Wentz and Ryan and the damage it’s done. One thing is obvious: the Colts can’t keep sitting on the sidelines when it comes to drafting a young passer. Ballard is going to have to take his shot at some point.
For all we like to point at GB for winning "only" two Super Bowls through Favre/Rodgers, Indy has had Peyton Manning and Andrew Luck fall into their laps and has won one. And it took injuries to two of the Bears' top 3 defenders and Rex Grossman at QB to get that.
Irsay is understandably spoiled at having those two great QBs. But it's been one failure after another with these vets.
Reich wasn't the greatest, but he got screwed over because Irsay's ego took over. They then made a disastrous interim HC hire and they're no closer today than they have been in the past 5 years.
They should - and I believe will - trade a haul for a QB and start over. That will benefit them in the long run. But at this point, I don't know why they'd keep Ballard or, frankly, why he'd want to stay. (except for that small fact that there are only 32 of these GM jobs.)
They are in need now of a total reset. I wouldn't be surprised if they went after a big name coach and offered a lot of control. Irsay won't do it for just anyone. Payton likely headed elsehwere, so that leads Indy back to their ol' pal, Jim Harbaugh. Starting with a new QB may entice him to take the job.