D.J. Moore
The Member
- Joined:
- Mar 22, 2016
- Posts:
- 1,115
- Liked Posts:
- 1,479
- Location:
- South Bend IN
My favorite teams
But not two super bowl mvps?
both should get him in
But not two super bowl mvps?
Jim Plunkett is a two time Super Bowl winning QB. Does he belong in the HOF? Then neither does Eli.
Even without accounting for family pedigree... slaying Belicheat, Brady and the Cheatriots twice alone cements his bust in Canton for me. His performances doubled the Lombardis in the Giants' trophy case. Floundering later in his career be damned. That is worth a lot.
I bet you any amount of money that if you gave Dan Marino the choice of trading away some of his career glory for a SB win he would do it in a heartbeat.
That second SB victory came VS a Joe Gibbs coached Washington team that was the 2nd best of the 80's.
He wasn't the greatest qb but two Super bowl mvp's against brady. Seems like a lock to me.
I never did like Eli, but it is hard to argue against over 200 games started in a row and 2 super bowl wins.
He eventually gets in.
Honestly, I think the big 3 from that draft all make it in, with Rivers being the Marino of the bunch.
Only one QB with two Super Bowls is not in the HOF. That is Jim Plunkett.
Edit: Shit, Tony beat me to it.
Sorry man. Neither a defense alone nor luck alone wins you 5 road playoff games PLUS two SBs against the Patriots. That is just ridiculous.
Eli Manning's career playoff passer rating is 87.4. Joe Flacco's is 88.6. If Flacco lucks into another Super Bowl win, does that make him HoF worthy?
Eli Manning's career playoff passer rating is 87.4. Joe Flacco's is 88.6. If Flacco lucks into another Super Bowl win, does that make him HoF worthy?