I agree the comparison with the Texans is apt but it was also expected given the Bears intentionally tore everything down. I saw a half of preseason football and immediately bet the under on wins because of how untalented the overall roster is. The biggest difference is the Bears have a QB while the Texans keep changing their coach every year while adding a bunch of low ceiling, culture first guys and doing nothing else with the roster. Maybe they get it right this year and draft a QB who becomes a great player, who knows?
But if you're asking me right now which position I'd rather be in, I'd rather be the Bears with a dynamic, play-making QB and $130 million in cap space to help rebuild the roster. As long as they don't go crazy overspending this offseason on bad contracts, they should be able to make some good additions the next couple years in both the draft and free agency to hopefully make them legit Super Bowl contenders 2-3 years from now.
You have more faith in Justin than I do, I am still a skeptic.
If I could see improvement in recognizing pressure and taking the outlet, I would be more hopeful.
Lets put it this way. Steve young was a spectacular quarterback from the pocket. He had touch and recognized what he faced play by play, and could be deadly nickel and diming down the field.
Despite that skill, despite that all pro line and all pro receivers, He cut short his career extending plays with his legs and piling up the concussions.
Fields has spectacular ability with his feet, But I have yet to see him demonstrate he can get it done from the pocket.
Now, cue the fanbois who will jump in here and whine about receivers and the line. Yup. They are not great. But that does not mean the 20 or 30 percent of plays where he can hit quick routes should be overlooked.
TL;DR, I have seen this type of player enough to know injuries are likely, There will absolutely be times when he is physically compromised, and it is unknown as of yet if he can slide in the pocket and make throws.
If he gets there, great. If he doesnt, it will not be unheard of. We have seen quite a few talented athletes facing the same questions, and the results vary wildly.