patg006
New member
- Joined:
- Apr 16, 2013
- Posts:
- 1,413
- Liked Posts:
- 986
- Location:
- Chicago
This is ultimately what I think both sides fail to see. There isn't a right or wrong in this circumstance. Managers make the wrong decision, based on all empirical evidence, and it works out for them. Baseball is so different from every sport in the North American landscape it is hard to accurately appreciate it. As much as people want to make it either about completely accepting or rejecting what the current front office has done, neither answer is truely correct. The front office is going to make mistakes like every front office has made. Hopefully they make fewer than others which is how the consisently successful teams have managed to do that. I have a few reasons to believe that will happen, but what they are doing right now could very well fail. So ultimately you are right on some things and others not so much. As are we all.
You say this as if all teams are on an even playing level with exactly the same resources; so everybody can just make mistakes because thats what team A would make.
The Dodgers and Padres dont have the same resources. Same with the Yankees and Rays, Angels and Athletics. A mistake for the Dodgers would be if Grienke were out injured for 2 years or just blows ass with his big deal. A mistake for the Athletics is getting Clayton Mortenson and Brett Wallace for Matt Holiday and neither lottery ticket live up to 1/4 of their potential. That's the difference and reason I think you're wrong trying to find "middle ground."
Sveum makes constant mistakes I'm sure he's told to make (Marmol as the closer for so long to keep his trade value up.) And I know theres some he makes (Benching his hottest hitter Schierholtz for the sake of a lefty pitching.) Overall, hes been a shitty manager with a shitty team.